Unbiasable

Upzoning · Housing & rent

When cities allow more homes to be built, do rents and prices come down?

Upzoning changes land-use rules so a site can hold more homes than before. Places have used it to allow duplexes, triplexes and townhouses in residential areas, or medium and high density housing where only low density was allowed.

2 sources

The answer so far

Results differ by place. Auckland’s study implies upzoning about doubled new permits within five years, and another estimates rents would be about 28% higher without it; Minneapolis showed no statistically significant change in multifamily construction. Where Houston relaxed minimum lot sizes, housing supply rose but prices also increased.

5 sources

Where it was tried

  1. Houston, Texas

    City Expanded Since 1998

    Houston reduced minimum lot sizes for single-family homes in reforms adopted in 1998 and 2013.

    Universitat de Barcelona, 2022
  2. Auckland

    City In force Since 2016

    Auckland upzoned about three-quarters of its residential land in 2016, and kept its abolition of minimum lot sizes for existing parcels.

    3 sources
  3. Oregon

    State In force Since 2019

    State law required cities of 25,000 or more, and cities and counties in a metropolitan service district, to allow middle housing where detached homes are allowed.

    2 sources
    • “Except as provided in subsection (4) of this section, each city with a population of 25,000 or more and each county or city within a metropolitan service district shall allow the development of: (a) All middle housing types in areas zoned for residential use that allow for the development of detached single-family dwellings;”

      Oregon Laws 2019, Chapter 639: House Bill 2001 Oregon Legislature, 2019 · Law or ruling

    • “Approved by the Governor August 8, 2019 Filed in the office of Secretary of State August 8, 2019 Effective date August 8, 2019”

      Oregon Laws 2019, Chapter 639: House Bill 2001 Oregon Legislature, 2019 · Law or ruling

  4. Minneapolis, Minnesota

    City In force Since 2020

    The Minneapolis 2040 Plan allowed up to three homes by right on lots once limited to one or two, removed minimum parking requirements, and promoted density downtown and along transit corridors.

    2 sources
  5. Massachusetts

    State In force Since 2021

    A 2021 Massachusetts law required each municipality in the MBTA service area to zone for multifamily housing by right.

    Town of Milton, Massachusetts, 2024
    • “In January 2021, the Massachusetts Legislature adopted an Economic Development Bond Bill (H.5250) that made changes to the state's Zoning Act. The "Housing Choice" sections of the bill made it easier for municipalities zoning changes related to housing growth and required each municipality in the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority (MBTA) service area to zone for multifamily housing by right.”

      MBTA Communities Multi-Family Zoning Requirement Town of Milton, Massachusetts, 2024 · Law or ruling The Town of Milton, a party to the state's lawsuit over the law

  6. California

    State In force Since 2022

    SB 9 lets eligible owners in single-family zones add homes or split a lot under a ministerial approval process.

    3 sources
    • “Senate Bill No. 9 (SB 9), signed into law by Governor Newsom on September 16, 2021, requires all local agencies to approve a proposed housing development containing no more than two residential units on a lot within a single-family residential zone, with a ministerial permit, if the development meets certain criteria as described below.”

      Senate Bill 9 Frequently Asked Questions Ventura County Resource Management Agency, 2022 · Law or ruling

    • “The legislation went into effect January 1, 2022.”

      Senate Bill 9 Frequently Asked Questions Ventura County Resource Management Agency, 2022 · Law or ruling

    • “The bill also allows the subdivision of one lot into two lots (“lot split”) within a single-family residential zone with a ministerial permit, if it meets certain criteria as described below.”

      Senate Bill 9 Frequently Asked Questions Ventura County Resource Management Agency, 2022 · Law or ruling

  7. Washington

    State In force Since 2023

    HB 1110 required covered communities to revise residential zoning so it allows middle housing.

    Washington State Department of Commerce, 2024

What the numbers did

Compared with similar places
Measured against places or people that did not adopt it.
Official figures over time
No comparison group, so other changes can blur it.

New dwelling permits per person

Went up

Greenaway-McGrevy’s synthetic control implies the upzoning about doubled new dwelling permits per capita within five years; over that time, permits per thousand residents rose from 5.95 to 12.57.

2 sources

Rents compared with no reform

Went down

Six years after the reform, Greenaway-McGrevy and So estimate Auckland rents would have been about 28% higher without it.

IDEAS/RePEc, 2024

Multifamily construction volume

No clear change

The Minneapolis Fed’s dashboard found no statistically significant difference in multifamily construction compared with its no-plan scenario.

Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, 2024
  • “The Minneapolis Fed’s dashboard shows no statistically significant difference in the volume of multifamily housing construction compared to what would have happened but for the plan in Minneapolis.”

    Minneapolis 2040 Plan data tool prepared to measure impacts Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, 2024 · Research organization

Minneapolis rent growth across data sources

Mixed

From 2019 to 2023, Apartment List showed Minneapolis rent falling 3.5 percent; CoStar and Zillow showed increases of 3.2 percent and 10.0 percent. All three figures were below comparison-city rent increases.

3 sources

Home prices and rent levels

Went down

Gu and Munro estimate home prices were 16-34% lower and rents 17.5-34% lower than a counterfactual Minneapolis over five years, an effect they attribute to weaker demand rather than new housing supply.

2 sources

Homes affordable at 50 percent of area median income

Mixed

The Fed found 20.3 percent of Minneapolis homes affordable to households earning 50 percent of area median income, compared with 18.1 percent in its comparison group; the gap was statistically significant but remained below the city’s 2014 peak of 27.8 percent.

2 sources
  • “Over the three-year period ending in 2022, 20.3 percent of homes in Minneapolis were affordable to households earning 50 percent of area median income (AMI)—compared to 18.1 percent in the comparison group.”

    Minneapolis 2040 Plan data tool prepared to measure impacts Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, 2024 · Research organization

  • “Although this difference is a statistically significant improvement compared to what would have been without the 2040 Plan, the 20.3 percent is still well below Minneapolis’ recent peak of 27.8 percent in 2014.”

    Minneapolis 2040 Plan data tool prepared to measure impacts Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, 2024 · Research organization

Housing supply, lot sizes, and prices

Mixed

Chaudhry found that where Houston’s 1998 reform relaxed minimum lot sizes, housing supply rose and lot sizes shrank, but prices also increased.

2 sources

Single-family home and land values

Went up

Shortell’s analysis of Houston’s 1998 and 2013 minimum-lot-size reforms found single-family home values rose relative to suburban values, driven by land-value increases.

2 sources

Permitting in MHA zones

Mixed

Seattle’s 2019 reform raised allowed density but required new projects to include or fund affordable housing; permitting fell in low-intensity rezonings, while the small share of high-intensity upzones saw more permitting.

Compared with similar places
2 sources
  • “This paper evaluates the effects of Seattle’s Mandatory Housing Affordability (MHA) program, a large-scale 2019 land use reform that simultaneously increased allowable housing density and required new developments to include or fund affordable housing.”

    Upzoning with strings attached: Evidence from Seattle’s affordable housing mandate Regional Science and Urban Economics, 2026 · Peer-reviewed study

  • “Declines were concentrated among low-intensity rezonings, indicating modest increases in allowable density did not offset added costs. By contrast, the small share of areas subject to high-intensity upzonings saw increased permitting, achieving the intended effect of the policy change.”

    Upzoning with strings attached: Evidence from Seattle’s affordable housing mandate Regional Science and Urban Economics, 2026 · Peer-reviewed study

New duplex, triplex, and fourplex buildings

Went up

The Minneapolis Fed reported that Minneapolis permitted 87 new duplex, triplex and fourplex buildings from 2020 to 2024, creating 225 new homes.

Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, 2025

SB 9 applications for new units

No clear change

In thirteen California cities, researchers found SB 9 activity limited or non-existent; Los Angeles had the most, with 211 applications for new units in 2022, and San Diego had seven.

3 sources

Where the studies disagree

Did Minneapolis’s zoning plan cause slower rent growth?

Gu and Munro found the reform reduced the growth of housing costs, with rents 17.5-34% lower than a counterfactual Minneapolis, which they attribute to weaker demand rather than new supply.

2 sources

The Minneapolis Fed said slower rent growth may reflect a negative housing demand shock specific to Minneapolis in 2020, more than expected effects of changes in housing supply.

Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, 2025
  • “However, our deeper dive into trends in rents and vacancies suggests that slow rent growth may result more from a negative housing demand shock specific to the Minneapolis market in 2020 than the expected impact of changes in the housing supply.”

    Unpacking supply and demand in rent trends since the Minneapolis 2040 Plan Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, 2025 · Research organization

Why they differ

Both studies point to weak demand rather than new supply. Gu and Munro credit the reform; the Fed says a Minneapolis-specific 2020 demand shock may explain slow rent growth more than the plan’s supply changes.

2 sources

Still open

Who is acting on it now

  1. Sued

    Andrea Joy CampbellMassachusetts Attorney General

    Attorney General Andrea Campbell sued nine towns over compliance with the 2021 multifamily zoning mandate.

    Boston.com, 2026
  2. Enacted

    Gavin NewsomGovernor of California

    Governor Gavin Newsom signed SB 79, allowing qualifying transit-oriented housing on sites near specified transit stops.

    2 sources
    • “SB 79, signed by Governor Newsom on October 10, 2025, is codified in Government Code sections 65912.155–65912.162. The California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) oversees compliance by reviewing local SB 79 ordinances and TOD alternative plans for substantial compliance.”

      SB 79 Transit-Oriented Development California Department of Housing and Community Development, 2026 · Law or ruling

    • “Senate Bill (SB) 79 makes qualifying “transit-oriented housing developments” (TOD) an allowed use on sites zoned for residential, mixed, or commercial development that are located near specified transit stops in urban transit counties.”

      SB 79 Transit-Oriented Development California Department of Housing and Community Development, 2026 · Law or ruling

  3. Blocked

    Massachusetts Supreme Judicial CourtState supreme court

    The state’s highest court upheld the MBTA Communities Act but declared its guidelines ineffective because they were not adopted under the Administrative Procedure Act.

    Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, 2025
    • “However, because the Executive Office of Housing and Livable Communities (HLC) did not comply with the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), G. L. c. 30A, when promulgating the guidelines, they are ineffective. For this reason, we grant declaratory relief in part and dismiss the remaining claims.”

      Attorney General v. Town of Milton (Mass. 2025) Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, 2025 · Law or ruling The Town of Milton, a party to the state's lawsuit over the law

  4. Ended

    Minnesota Court of AppealsState appellate court

    The Minnesota Court of Appeals reversed an injunction that had barred Minneapolis from implementing the residential development portions of its 2040 Plan.

    2 sources
    • “We conclude that, although the district court did not violate our remand instructions, the district court did abuse its discretion in ordering injunctive relief that is based on legal error, that is unsupported by the evidence in the record, and that imposes unnecessary hardship on appellant. We therefore reverse the amended injunction order.”

      Court of Appeals Opinion Minnesota Court of Appeals, 2024 · Law or ruling

    • “Under the amended injunction order, the city was “immediately enjoined from any ongoing implementation of the residential development portions of the” 2040 Plan”

      State of Minnesota by Smart Growth Minneapolis v. City of Minneapolis, A23-1382 Minnesota Court of Appeals, 2024 · Law or ruling

  5. Voted against

    Milton votersTown voters

    Milton residents struck down a plan to allow more multifamily housing, opening the town to legal challenges from the state.

    WBUR, 2024
    • “Milton residents struck down a plan to allow for more multifamily housing, opening the town to legal challenges with the state. The plan would have brought Milton into compliance with a law that requires cities and towns along MBTA corridors to allow for higher density housing.”

      Milton voters reject multifamily rezoning plan WBUR, 2024 · News report The Town of Milton, a party to the state's lawsuit over the law

Sources

Peer-reviewed study1

Working paper6

Research organization3

Law or ruling8

News report2

Before the next fight over it

See what happened where they tried it.

The brief follows what politicians propose each morning, in their own words, and links the policy pages when one comes up. Free.

Arrives around 6am ET. Free, and it stays that way.

Cancel anytime. Nothing on the site goes behind a paywall.

One payment through Stripe. No account needed.