Unbiasable

Congestion pricing · Climate & energy

When cities charged drivers to enter downtown, did traffic and air get better?

Congestion pricing uses prices to manage traffic flow. One form charges fixed or variable fees for driving into or within a city zone.

2 sources

The answer so far

Traffic fell after charging began in New York, London, Stockholm and Singapore; New York’s toll operator reported entries about 11 percent below baseline. New York’s health department found air quality stable or slightly improved, continuing a 20-year trend. In London, congestion in the original zone was back to its 2002 level by 2007.

5 sources
  • “In every month since tolling began, average daily vehicle entries have been below the baseline. Between January and October, entries to the CRZ and excluded roadways are approximately 11 percent lower on average than the baseline.”

    Congestion Relief Zone Tolling First Evaluation Report MTA Bridges & Tunnels, 2026 · Government evaluation The agency that runs New York's toll, reporting on its own program

  • “August 14, 2026 — Today, the New York City Health Department released its first comprehensive evaluation of the Congestion Relief Zone Tolling Program’s impact on neighborhood air quality, determining that the city’s air quality remained stable or improved slightly in the first year of congestion pricing, continuing a 20-year trend of improving air quality and declining pollution.”

    Congestion Pricing Continues a 20-Year Improvement in Air Quality Across NYC New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, 2026 · Government evaluation

  • “UVARs in Stockholm have made the city more accessible – reducing queueing time by between 30% and 50%, and traffic volumes by between 20% and 25%. In addition, reductions in dangerous emissions such as carbon monoxide (14%), PM10 (13%) and volatile organic compounds (13%) have resulted in air quality improvements across the city (DG MOVE, 2017).”

    Stockholm: Achieving sustainable mobility using urban vehicle access regulations European Commission Urban Mobility Observatory, 2018 · Government evaluation

  • “Traffic levels during the morning peak remained significantly below the pre-ALS level well into the 1980s: while 74 000 vehicles entered the Restricted Zone daily in March 1975, prior to the ALS, an estimated 51 000 vehicles entered daily in 1988.”

    Congestion Control in Singapore International Transport Forum, OECD, 2020 · Research organization

  • “In the original central London charging zone, congestion has further intensified in 2007. The average measurement of congestion in the original central zone during charging hours in 2007 was identical to the representative value for 2002 used by TfL to reflect pre charging conditions.”

    Central London Congestion Charging Impacts Monitoring: Sixth Annual Report Transport for London, 2008 · Government evaluation The agency that runs London's charge, reporting on its own scheme

Where it was tried

  1. Singapore

    City Ended Jun 2, 1975 to Sep 1, 1998

    Singapore charged for entry to its downtown Restricted Zone under the Area Licensing Scheme, then replaced it with electronic road pricing in 1998.

    2 sources
    • “The first congestion charging scheme, the Restricted Zone and Area Licenses Scheme, was implemented on 2 June 1975 (S.L. 38 of 1975) under Section 70 and Section 90 of the Road Traffic Act.”

      Congestion Control in Singapore International Transport Forum, OECD, 2020 · Research organization

    • “The ALS continued in force, with periodic amendments that generally extended the hours of operation, abolished exemptions for most types of vehicles including carpools, and varied daily charges, until 1 September 1998 when it was revoked and replaced by the Electronic Road Pricing System.”

      Congestion Control in Singapore International Transport Forum, OECD, 2020 · Research organization

  2. London, England

    City In force Since Feb 2003

    London started its central congestion charge in February 2003; TfL raised the daily charge to £18 in January 2026.

    2 sources
  3. Milan

    City In force Since 2012

    Milan converted its Ecopass pollution charge into the Area C congestion charge in 2012.

    OECD, 2013
    • “Following the results of a local referendum held in June 2011, the Ecopass was converted to the so-called “Area C” programme in January 2012, moving from a pollution charge to a daily congestion charge of EUR 5 for private vehicles entering the city centre in working hours during the week and EUR 10 for freight vehicles.”

      OECD Environmental Performance Reviews: Italy 2013 OECD, 2013 · Research organization

  4. New York City, New York

    City In force Since Jan 5, 2025

    New York began charging vehicles entering the Congestion Relief Zone in Manhattan on January 5, 2025.

    MTA Bridges & Tunnels, 2026
    • “On January 5, 2025, the Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority (TBTA) began tolling vehicles entering the Congestion Relief Zone (CRZ).”

      Congestion Relief Zone Tolling First Evaluation Report MTA Bridges & Tunnels, 2026 · Government evaluation The agency that runs New York's toll, reporting on its own program

What the numbers did

Compared with similar places
Measured against places or people that did not adopt it.
Before and after
The same place before and after; other changes at the time can blur it.
Official figures over time
No comparison group, so other changes can blur it.

Neighborhood air pollution

No clear change

The Health Department’s first-year evaluation found air quality stable or slightly improved, continuing a 20-year trend, using a model with a control that adjusts for weather and seasonal trends.

2 sources
  • “August 14, 2026 — Today, the New York City Health Department released its first comprehensive evaluation of the Congestion Relief Zone Tolling Program’s impact on neighborhood air quality, determining that the city’s air quality remained stable or improved slightly in the first year of congestion pricing, continuing a 20-year trend of improving air quality and declining pollution.”

    Congestion Pricing Continues a 20-Year Improvement in Air Quality Across NYC New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, 2026 · Government evaluation

  • “This is called an interrupted time series study with control. In addition, the model takes into account temperature, wind and precipitation, and both long term and seasonal trends in air pollution. To date, the Health Department’s analysis is the most comprehensive evaluation of congestion pricing’s impact on air quality.”

    Air Quality Impacts of Congestion Relief Zone Tolling New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, 2026 · Government evaluation

Manhattan activity and shopping trips

Mixed

The working paper found geographic measures suggested Manhattan activity fell; mobility measures found no net reduction but a shift from shopping and grocery trips. It also analyzed 138 metropolitan areas in eight countries, where geographic and mobility-network distances diverged locally.

2 sources

Vehicles entering the zone and excluded roads

Went down

The MTA, which runs the toll, reported entries to the zone about 11 percent below baseline from January to October 2025, and 21.5 million fewer entries than it estimates without tolling.

2 sources
  • “In every month since tolling began, average daily vehicle entries have been below the baseline. Between January and October, entries to the CRZ and excluded roadways are approximately 11 percent lower on average than the baseline.”

    Congestion Relief Zone Tolling First Evaluation Report MTA Bridges & Tunnels, 2026 · Government evaluation The agency that runs New York's toll, reporting on its own program

  • “This represents an average reduction of approximately 2.16 million vehicles entering the CRZ and excluded roadways each month, totaling more than 21.5 million fewer entries between January 5, 2025, and October 31, 2025 than would have occurred without tolling.”

    Congestion Relief Zone Tolling First Evaluation Report MTA Bridges & Tunnels, 2026 · Government evaluation The agency that runs New York's toll, reporting on its own program

AM crossing speeds and bus ridership

Went up

The MTA reported weekday morning speeds on crossings into the zone from New Jersey, Brooklyn and Queens up 23 percent on 2024, and bus ridership up 13.4 percent from January to September 2025.

2 sources
  • “Since tolling began, through October 2025, average speeds on crossings entering the CRZ during the weekday morning commute (6:00 a.m. to 10 a.m.) from New Jersey, Brooklyn, and Queens have all improved, by an average of 23 percent compared to 2024. The biggest improvements have been at the Holland Tunnel, Williamsburg Bridge, and Ed Koch Queensboro Bridge.”

    Congestion Relief Zone Tolling First Evaluation Report MTA Bridges & Tunnels, 2026 · Government evaluation The agency that runs New York's toll, reporting on its own program

  • “Between January and September 2025, all services saw increases in ridership compared to the same period of 2024. Access-A-Ride saw the largest gain, with an 18.7 percent increase in average daily ridership, followed by buses with a 13.4 percent increase. Long Island Rail Road (LIRR), Metro-North Railroad (MNR), and the subway saw between seven and 10 percent increases.”

    Congestion Relief Zone Tolling First Evaluation Report MTA Bridges & Tunnels, 2026 · Government evaluation The agency that runs New York's toll, reporting on its own program

Zone traffic and morning-peak passengers

Mixed

TfL’s 2004 report recorded 18 per cent fewer entries and 15 per cent less circulating traffic during charging hours. It also noted more than 29,000 extra passengers entering the zone in the three hour morning peak.

3 sources
  • “Traffic congestion has been reduced in and around central London as a result of the central London congestion charging scheme introduced in February 2003. In April 2004, TfL published its Second Annual Impacts Monitoring Report on congestion charging, which highlighted that the scheme has reduced traffic delays by 30 per cent within the charging zone and made journeys to, from and within the zone quicker, easier and more reliable.”

    TfL Annual Report 2003–2004 Transport for London, 2004 · Government evaluation The agency that runs London's charge, reporting on its own scheme

  • “Traffic entering the zone during charging hours has reduced by 18 per cent and traffic circulating within the zone has reduced by 15 per cent.”

    TfL Annual Report 2003–2004 Transport for London, 2004 · Government evaluation The agency that runs London's charge, reporting on its own scheme

  • “More than 29,000 extra passengers are now entering the congestion charging zone in the three hour morning peak period, with many using the new buses and the five new routes specifically introduced as part of the scheme.”

    TfL Annual Report 2003–2004 Transport for London, 2004 · Government evaluation The agency that runs London's charge, reporting on its own scheme

Traffic and pollutant levels

Went down

A European Commission case study of Stockholm reported traffic volumes down 20% to 25%, with emissions of carbon monoxide down 14%, PM10 down 13% and volatile organic compounds down 13%.

Before and after
European Commission Urban Mobility Observatory, 2018
  • “UVARs in Stockholm have made the city more accessible – reducing queueing time by between 30% and 50%, and traffic volumes by between 20% and 25%. In addition, reductions in dangerous emissions such as carbon monoxide (14%), PM10 (13%) and volatile organic compounds (13%) have resulted in air quality improvements across the city (DG MOVE, 2017).”

    Stockholm: Achieving sustainable mobility using urban vehicle access regulations European Commission Urban Mobility Observatory, 2018 · Government evaluation

Daily vehicle entries to the Restricted Zone

Went down

The OECD reported 74 000 vehicles entered Singapore’s Restricted Zone daily in March 1975 before the Area Licensing Scheme; an estimated 51 000 entered daily in 1988.

International Transport Forum, OECD, 2020
  • “Traffic levels during the morning peak remained significantly below the pre-ALS level well into the 1980s: while 74 000 vehicles entered the Restricted Zone daily in March 1975, prior to the ALS, an estimated 51 000 vehicles entered daily in 1988.”

    Congestion Control in Singapore International Transport Forum, OECD, 2020 · Research organization

Toll revenue

Went up

The MTA reported toll revenue averaging $57.3 million a month in 2025 through October, against monthly operating expenses of $10.5 million.

MTA Bridges & Tunnels, 2026
  • “Monthly toll revenue is expected to fluctuate seasonally in line with traffic patterns (see the Traffic and Congestion chapter). Table 6-1 includes monthly actuals through October. For 2025 YTD, monthly revenue averaged $57.3 million and monthly expenses averaged $10.5 million. Net revenue represents toll revenue less operating expenses. Operating expenses exclude debt service related to CRZ infrastructure financing of approximately $1.6 million per month.”

    Congestion Relief Zone Tolling First Evaluation Report MTA Bridges & Tunnels, 2026 · Government evaluation The agency that runs New York's toll, reporting on its own program

Where the studies disagree

Did London’s early congestion reduction persist?

TfL’s early monitoring found traffic delays in the central zone were 30 percent lower in its 2004 report.

Transport for London, 2004
  • “Traffic congestion has been reduced in and around central London as a result of the central London congestion charging scheme introduced in February 2003. In April 2004, TfL published its Second Annual Impacts Monitoring Report on congestion charging, which highlighted that the scheme has reduced traffic delays by 30 per cent within the charging zone and made journeys to, from and within the zone quicker, easier and more reliable.”

    TfL Annual Report 2003–2004 Transport for London, 2004 · Government evaluation The agency that runs London's charge, reporting on its own scheme

TfL’s later report found congestion in the original zone during 2007 matched its representative 2002 pre-charge level.

Transport for London, 2008
  • “In the original central London charging zone, congestion has further intensified in 2007. The average measurement of congestion in the original central zone during charging hours in 2007 was identical to the representative value for 2002 used by TfL to reflect pre charging conditions.”

    Central London Congestion Charging Impacts Monitoring: Sixth Annual Report Transport for London, 2008 · Government evaluation The agency that runs London's charge, reporting on its own scheme

Why they differ

The reports cover different periods. TfL, which runs the charge, said a rise in roadworks and streetworks worsened conditions in 2005 and 2006, and that comparing with the fixed 2002 baseline was becoming inappropriate.

2 sources
  • “In view of changed priorities for the use of the road network in central London, reflecting various mayoral and borough initiatives, continued comparison of post charging conditions against a static baseline reflecting conditions in 2002, before the introduction of the original scheme, was increasingly inappropriate.”

    Central London Congestion Charging Impacts Monitoring: Sixth Annual Report Transport for London, 2008 · Government evaluation The agency that runs London's charge, reporting on its own scheme

  • “A substantial increase in road and street works, reflecting the sub-surface infrastructure replacement programme, had been an important factor contributing to the deterioration of conditions in the original central London zone in 2005 and 2006.”

    Central London Congestion Charging Impacts Monitoring: Sixth Annual Report Transport for London, 2008 · Government evaluation The agency that runs London's charge, reporting on its own scheme

Do methods give the same picture of Manhattan activity?

The working paper’s geographic analysis suggested a decline in activity in Manhattan.

arXiv, 2026

Its mobility-based analysis found no net activity reduction, but a shift away from shopping and grocery destinations.

arXiv, 2026

Why they differ

The authors used geographic and mobility-based exposure definitions. They report that geographic and mobility-network distances diverge locally in every city they studied.

2 sources

Still open

Who is acting on it now

  1. Appealed

    Sean Duffy, Gloria M. Shepherd, U.S. Department of Transportation and Federal Highway AdministrationFederal transportation officials and agencies

    The federal government appealed a district court decision in favor of the MTA in New York’s congestion-pricing case.

    amNewYork, 2026
  2. Changed

    Transport for LondonLondon transport agency

    From 2 January 2026, TfL raised the daily charge to £18 if paid on the day or in advance, or £21 if paid within 3 days after travel.

    Transport for London, 2026
  3. Proposed

    County Council of Durham Highways CommitteeLocal highway authority

    The Highways Committee endorsed a proposal to raise Durham’s road charge and extend its hours to 2am, seven days a week.

    Open Council Network, 2025
    • “The committee endorsed proposed changes to the Traffic Regulation Order (TRO) in Durham City, including increasing the road user charge from £2 to £5 and extending its operating hours from 10am-4pm to 10am-2am, seven days a week.”

      County Durham Highways Committee, 15 April 2025 Open Council Network, 2025 · News report

Sources

Government evaluation7

Working paper1

Research organization2

Law or ruling1

Before the next fight over it

See what happened where they tried it.

The brief follows what politicians propose each morning, in their own words, and links the policy pages when one comes up. Free.

Arrives around 6am ET. Free, and it stays that way.

Cancel anytime. Nothing on the site goes behind a paywall.

One payment through Stripe. No account needed.