Unbiasable

School vouchers · Education & schools

When states paid for private school, did test scores go up?

School vouchers use public funds for private-school tuition; tax-credit scholarships use tax-subsidized donations. Education savings accounts deposit public money in a restricted account that families can spend on private school and other approved learning costs.

3 sources
  • “School vouchers increase access to private schooling by providing families of eligible children with a portion of public funding that would have been spent on that student’s public schooling. Tax-credit scholarships incentivize individual and business taxpayers to donate to nonprofit scholarship organizations by providing tax credits for their contributions.”

    Distribution of Education Savings Accounts Usage Among Families: Evidence from the Florida Gardiner Program EdWorkingPaper / Annenberg Institute at Brown University, 2021 · Working paper Co-author Martin Lueken works at EdChoice, a group that advocates school choice

  • “ESAs are education funding mechanisms that allow for families to receive a deposit of public funds to a government-authorized savings account.”

    Distribution of Education Savings Accounts Usage Among Families: Evidence from the Florida Gardiner Program EdWorkingPaper / Annenberg Institute at Brown University, 2021 · Working paper Co-author Martin Lueken works at EdChoice, a group that advocates school choice

  • “While voucher and tax-credit scholarships are limited to private schools, ESAs hold restricted funds to provide access to a host of educational services including online learning programs, private tutoring, community college expenses, higher education costs, and other approved customized learning services and materials instead of being limited to payment of private school tuition and fees.”

    Distribution of Education Savings Accounts Usage Among Families: Evidence from the Florida Gardiner Program EdWorkingPaper / Annenberg Institute at Brown University, 2021 · Working paper Co-author Martin Lueken works at EdChoice, a group that advocates school choice

The answer so far

A Louisiana lottery study found vouchers lowered math scores 0.4 standard deviations, and Indiana students who switched lost 0.12; three-year studies in Louisiana and D.C. found no statistically significant effects. In Milwaukee, choice students gained 2.4 math percentile points a year and were 7 percentage points likelier to enroll in four-year universities. In Florida, fifty-seven percent of scholarship students enrolled in college, against 51 percent of peers.

9 sources

Where it was tried

  1. Milwaukee, Wisconsin

    City In force Since 1990

    Wisconsin pays participating private schools for eligible Milwaukee students through the Parental Choice Program.

    2 sources
    • “Beginning in the 1990-91 school year, the legislation allows pupils enrolled in grades kindergarten to 12 who are members of families with incomes that do not exceed 1.75 times the federal poverty level to attend any nonsectarian private school located in the City of Milwaukee that is participating in the program.”

      Milwaukee Parental Choice Program Wisconsin Legislative Council Staff, 1990 · Government evaluation

    • “Private schools receive a payment from the state for each eligible student attending the school under a choice program. For the 2022-23 school year, the state will pay private schools participating in the Milwaukee, Racine, or Statewide Program $8,399 for each eligible K-8 student and $9,045 for each 9th to 12th grade student.”

      Parental Choice Programs in Private Schools Wisconsin Legislative Council, 2022 · Government evaluation

  2. Florida

    State Expanded Since 2001

    Florida gives tax credits for donations to scholarship groups, and removed financial eligibility limits starting in the 2023-24 school year.

    2 sources
    • “Established in 2001 the FTC Scholarship Program provides that SFOs may solicit and receive eligible contributions that entitle donors to a 100 percent State tax credit against corporate income tax, insurance premium tax, alcoholic beverage excise tax, direct-pay sales tax, and oil and gas severance tax.”

      Florida Auditor General Report No. 2026-046 Florida Auditor General, 2025 · Government evaluation

    • “Financial eligibility restrictions for both the FES-EO and FTC Programs were also eliminated starting with the 2023-24 school year.”

      Florida Auditor General Report No. 2026-046 Florida Auditor General, 2025 · Government evaluation

  3. District of Columbia

    City In force Since 2004

    Congress created federally funded scholarships to help eligible District families send children to private schools.

    3 sources
    • “The District of Columbia School Choice Incentive Act of 2003 was passed by Congress in January 2004. The Act provided funds for District of Columbia Public Schools (DCPS) improvement activities and charter school facility acquisitions.”

      Evaluation of the DC Opportunity Scholarship Program: First Year Report on Participation Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education, 2005 · Government evaluation

    • “Most notably, the statute established what is now called the DC Opportunity Scholarship Program―the first federal government initiative to provide K-12 education scholarships, or vouchers, to families to send their children to private schools of choice.”

      Evaluation of the DC Opportunity Scholarship Program: First Year Report on Participation Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education, 2005 · Government evaluation

    • “The D.C. Opportunity Scholarship Program (OSP) awards need-based annual scholarships to eligible District children to attend a participating private D.C. elementary, middle, or high school of their parent’s choice.”

      For Parents Serving Our Children, D.C. OSP program administrator, 2026 · Law or ruling The program's own administrator

  4. Louisiana

    State Expanded Since 2008

    Louisiana began the program as a New Orleans pilot before expanding it statewide.

    Education Research Alliance for New Orleans, Tulane University; School Choice Demonstration Project, University of Arkansas, 2017
  5. Arizona

    State Expanded Since 2011

    Arizona launched education savings accounts and later extended eligibility to all K-12 students.

    2 sources
    • “In 2011, Arizona passed and launched the Empowerment Scholarship Accounts program.”

      Distribution of Education Savings Accounts Usage Among Families: Evidence from the Florida Gardiner Program EdWorkingPaper / Annenberg Institute at Brown University, 2021 · Working paper Co-author Martin Lueken works at EdChoice, a group that advocates school choice

    • “Expands, beginning the 2022-2023 school year, the definition of qualified student to include an Arizona resident who is eligible to enroll in an Arizona public school in a preschool program for children with disabilities, a kindergarten program or any of the 1st-12th grades and who does not otherwise qualify for an ESA. (Sec. 2)”

      HB2853 - 552R - House Bill Summary Arizona Legislature, 2022 · Law or ruling

  6. Indiana

    State Expanded Since 2011

    Indiana created tuition scholarships for income-eligible students and later broadened eligibility through state laws.

    2 sources
    • “The Choice Scholarship Program was passed as part of House Enrolled Act 1003-2011 (Public Law 92-2011) and provides Choice Scholarships to students in households that meet eligibility and income requirements. The program provides funds to assist with the payment of tuition and fees at a participating Choice school.”

      Digest of Public School Finance Indiana Department of Education, 2023 · Official data

    • “During the 2023 session, the age requirement expanded, the income eligibility was expanded, and all eligibility tracks were repealed.”

      Digest of Public School Finance Indiana Department of Education, 2023 · Official data

  7. Illinois

    State Ended 2017 to Dec 31, 2023

    Illinois gave tax credits for donations that scholarship organizations used to fund private-school scholarships.

    3 sources
    • “Illinois enacted the Invest In Kids Scholarship Tax Credit Program in 2017. This program offered a 75 percent income tax credit to individuals and businesses that contribute to qualified Scholarship Granting Organizations (SGOs).”

      Invest in Kids Illinois Department of Revenue, 2024 · Law or ruling

    • “The SGOs then provided scholarships for students whose families met the income requirements to attend qualified, non-public schools and technical academies in Illinois.”

      Invest in Kids Illinois Department of Revenue, 2024 · Law or ruling

    • “The Invest in Kids Tax Credit Program expired on December 31, 2023.”

      Invest in Kids Illinois Department of Revenue, 2024 · Law or ruling

  8. Iowa

    State In force Since 2023

    Iowa created state-funded accounts for tuition, fees, and other qualified expenses at accredited nonpublic schools.

    Iowa Department of Education, 2026
    • “The Students First Act, introduced by Governor Reynolds and signed into law on January 24, 2023, makes state funding available to support the success of every K-12 student in Iowa. The bill established a framework and funding for education savings accounts (ESAs), which may be used by eligible families to cover tuition, fees, and other qualified education expenses at accredited nonpublic schools in Iowa.”

      Students First Education Savings Accounts Iowa Department of Education, 2026 · Law or ruling

  9. Texas

    State In force Since 2026

    Texas created education savings accounts to fund approved education-related expenses for participating children.

    2 sources
    • “C.S.S.B. 2 amends the Education Code to require the comptroller of public accounts to establish an education savings account program, applicable beginning with the 2026-2027 school year except as otherwise provided, to provide funding for approved education-related expenses of children participating in the program.”

      Bill Analysis: Senate Bill 2 Texas Legislative Council, 2025 · Law or ruling

    • “Senate Bill 2 (Creighton/Buckley) establishes an Education Savings Account program allowing eligible students to direct funding toward their choice of preapproved educational providers and services such as private school tuition, instructional materials, and educational therapies. With $1 billion in funding for the 2026-2027 school year, the program will be the largest day-one launch in the country.”

      Governor Abbott Signs Landmark School Choice Legislation Into Law Office of the Texas Governor, 2025 · Law or ruling The governor's office describing its own action

What the numbers did

Randomized trial
Who got it was decided at random, so the two groups started out alike.
Compared with similar places
Measured against places or people that did not adopt it.
Before and after
The same place before and after; other changes at the time can blur it.
Official figures over time
No comparison group, so other changes can blur it.

Math scores for voucher users

Went down

A National Bureau of Economic Research lottery study found attending a Louisiana Scholarship Program school lowered math scores by 0.4 standard deviations; effects on reading, science and social studies were also negative and large.

3 sources

Louisiana Year 3 test effects

No clear change

Mills and Wolf found Year 3 English results positive and math results negative, neither statistically significant; they said this partly reflects declining statistical power and students returning to public schools.

4 sources

D.C. reading and math scores

No clear change

The IES evaluation found no statistically significant reading or math impacts three years after application; students offered scholarships scored 0.1 percentile points higher in math and 1.6 lower in reading.

Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education, 2019
  • “There were no statistically significant impacts on either reading or mathematics achievement three years after students applied to the program. Students in the group that received a scholarship offer scored 0.1 percentile points higher on the mathematics test, and 1.6 percentile points lower on the reading test, than students in the control group (figure 2) after three years.”

    Evaluation of the DC Opportunity Scholarship Program: Impacts Three Years After Students Applied Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education, 2019 · Government evaluation

Share of public-school students meeting state test standards

Mixed

Canbolat analyzed 1,268 schools in 283 Indiana districts and found early positive associations between voucher competition and the share meeting state test standards, followed by declines as high-achieving students moved to private schools.

Compared with similar places Indiana
2 sources

Indiana public-school achievement and graduation

No clear change

Egalite and Catt found largely null effects on Indiana public-school math, ELA, and high school graduation.

Compared with similar places Indiana
AERA Open, 2025

Milwaukee math scores

Went up

Rouse’s Milwaukee comparison found choice-school students’ math scores rose an additional 2.4 percentile points per year. A percentile point reflects position relative to other test takers.

2 sources

Milwaukee college enrollment

Went up

An Urban Institute study found Milwaukee voucher students were 7 percentage points more likely to enroll in a four-year university.

Urban Institute, 2019

Florida college enrollment

Went up

Fifty-seven percent of Florida Tax Credit Scholarship students enrolled in college, compared with 51 percent of non-FTC students in Urban’s comparison.

Compared with similar places Florida
2 sources

Iowa private-school tuition

Went up

Fontana and Jennings estimated Iowa tuition rose 21-25% in universal kindergarten and 10-16% in grades with partial ESA eligibility.

Compared with similar places Iowa
Annenberg Institute at Brown University, EdWorkingPapers, 2024

Math scores of Indiana students who switched to private schools

Went down

Berends, Waddington, and Austin found voucher switchers lost 0.12 standard deviations in math from baseline, with the largest losses in years one and two.

UCLA Civil Rights Project, 2018
  • “Overall, we found an average loss in mathematics of 0.12 standard deviations (roughly 3-4 percentile points) from baseline for students who used a voucher to transfer from public to private schools. The largest losses occurred during years one and two.”

    Impacts of Indiana Voucher Program UCLA Civil Rights Project, 2018 · Research organization

Arizona ESA enrollment and participant origin

Went up

Arizona ESA enrollment rose from 12,127 in 2021-22 to 61,689 in 2022-23; 71.2% of new universal-account participants had not attended public school.

Official figures over time Arizona
2 sources

Where the studies disagree

How do Louisiana’s lottery and Year 3 estimates compare?

The NBER lottery study found attending an LSP-eligible private school lowered math scores by 0.4 standard deviations.

2 sources

Mills and Wolf reported positive English language arts and negative math effects in Year 3, with neither difference statistically significant.

Education Research Alliance for New Orleans, Tulane University; School Choice Demonstration Project, University of Arkansas, 2017

Why they differ

The NBER report compares lottery winners and losers; Mills and Wolf studied the 2012-13 cohort three years after statewide expansion and say their results partly reflect declining statistical power and students returning to public schools.

3 sources

Why do Indiana public-school studies disagree?

Canbolat found early positive associations, then lower school proficiency where voucher competition was higher as high-achieving students left.

Education Policy Analysis Archives, 2021

Egalite and Catt found largely null effects on math, ELA, and high school graduation among Indiana public-school students.

AERA Open, 2025

Why they differ

Canbolat used school-level proficiency rates and district voucher share. Egalite and Catt used a difference-in-differences framework to examine math, English language arts and graduation.

2 sources

Still open

Who is acting on it now

  1. Proposed

    Kathy HochulGovernor of New York

    Hochul said New York will take part in the federal scholarship tax credit, in hopes of generating millions of dollars for public school students.

    Chalkbeat, 2026
  2. Vetoed

    Katie HobbsGovernor of Arizona

    Hobbs vetoed a bill that would have opted Arizona into a federal tax-credit program for private-school scholarships.

    KJZZ / Cronkite News, 2026
  3. Vetoed

    Tony EversGovernor of Wisconsin

    Evers vetoed a bill that would have opted Wisconsin into what his office called a nationwide expansion of private voucher schools under the federal Big Beautiful Bill.

    Office of Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers, 2026
    • “MADISON — Gov. Tony Evers today vetoed a bill that would have required opting Wisconsin into a nationwide expansion of private voucher schools under President Donald Trump’s and Republicans’ ‘Big Beautiful Bill, which is expected to divert billions of dollars from public schools and public education.”

      Gov. Evers Vetoes Bill Requiring Wisconsin to Opt Into Nationwide Expansion of Private Voucher Schools Office of Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers, 2026 · Law or ruling The governor's office describing its own action

  4. Enacted

    U.S. CongressCongress

    Congress enacted a federal tax credit for contributions to scholarship-granting organizations, with states choosing whether to participate.

    2 sources
    • “SEC. 70411. TAX CREDIT FOR CONTRIBUTIONS OF INDIVIDUALS TO SCHOLARSHIP GRANTING ORGANIZATIONS.”

      Public Law 119-21 U.S. Government Publishing Office, 2025 · Law or ruling

    • “(1) COVERED STATE.—The term ‘covered State’ means one of the States, or the District of Columbia, that, for a calendar year, voluntarily elects to participate under this section and to identify scholarship granting organizations in the State, in accordance with subsection (g).”

      Public Law 119-21 U.S. Government Publishing Office, 2025 · Law or ruling

  5. Enacted

    Greg AbbottGovernor of Texas

    Abbott signed Senate Bill 2, the Texas school choice program, into law.

    Office of the Texas Governor, 2025
    • “Governor Greg Abbott today signed Senate Bill 2, the landmark school choice program that is the largest day-one launch in the country, into law at the Governor’s Mansion in Austin.”

      Governor Abbott Signs Landmark School Choice Legislation Into Law Office of the Texas Governor, 2025 · Law or ruling The governor's office describing its own action

  6. Voted against

    Kentucky votersVoters

    Kentucky voters rejected Amendment Two, which would have opened the way for private school vouchers if lawmakers changed the state constitution.

    WSAZ, 2024
    • “Voters rejected Amendment Two, which would create the possibility for private school vouchers to be allowed, should lawmakers choose to change the state constitution during the 2025 legislative session.”

      Kentucky voters reject school choice ballot measure WSAZ, 2024 · News report

Sources

Official data1

Government evaluation5

Working paper4

Research organization4

Law or ruling8

Before the next fight over it

See what happened where they tried it.

The brief follows what politicians propose each morning, in their own words, and links the policy pages when one comes up. Free.

Arrives around 6am ET. Free, and it stays that way.

Cancel anytime. Nothing on the site goes behind a paywall.

One payment through Stripe. No account needed.