Unbiasable

Guaranteed income · Economy, jobs & inflation

What happened when people got monthly cash with no strings attached?

Guaranteed income is a regular cash payment recipients can use freely, without tying it to work or spending rules. Pilots often run for a set time, while Alaska pays residents a yearly dividend.

3 sources
  • “Researchers evaluated the impact of receiving US$1,000 of unrestricted cash per month for three years on individuals’ spending and financial health. Individuals in the comparison group received US$50 per month for the same period of time. These monthly payments were not conditional on participant behavior or study participation.”

    The Impact of Unconditional Cash Transfers on Consumption and Household Balance Sheets in the United States J-PAL, 2024 · Research organization

  • “Since 1982, all Alaskan residents have received a yearly cash dividend from the Alaska Permanent Fund. Using the Current Population Survey and a synthetic control method, this paper shows that the dividend had no effect on employment and increased part-time work by 1.8 percentage points (17 percent).”

    The Labor Market Impacts of Universal and Permanent Cash Transfers: Evidence from the Alaska Permanent Fund American Economic Association, 2022 · Peer-reviewed study

  • “Launched in 2022, the Cook County Promise Guaranteed Income Pilot was the largest publicly funded program of its kind in the nation. Leveraging $42 million in federal funding provided by the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA), the two-year pilot provided monthly, no-strings-attached payments of $500 to 3,250 households. The final payments were distributed to participants in January 2025.”

    President Preckwinkle Unveils Next Phase of Guaranteed Income in Cook County Cook County Government, 2025 · Government evaluation The county that funded and ran the pilot

The answer so far

In a randomized trial of $1,000 a month, the share working or looking for work fell 4.2 percentage points and paid hours fell 1-2 a week. Alaska’s yearly dividend had no overall employment effect and raised part-time work 1.8 percentage points. In Stockton’s randomized trial, employment shifts were not statistically significant.

6 sources

Where it was tried

  1. Alaska

    State In force Since 1982

    Alaska has paid all residents a yearly dividend from the Permanent Fund since 1982.

    American Economic Association, 2022
  2. Finland

    National Pilot ended 2017 to 2018

    Finland ran a basic-income pilot with 2,000 people from January 1, 2017, to December 31, 2018.

    This is Finland, 2017
    • “Between January 1, 2017 and December 31, 2018, Finland is piloting a basic-income programme with 2,000 people to see if it holds the key to increasing employment and simplifying the social security system.”

      A great adventure: Finland begins basic-income experiment This is Finland, 2017 · News report

  3. Stockton, California

    City Pilot ended 2019 to 2021

    SEED ran a randomized guaranteed-income trial in Stockton from February 2019 to January 2021.

    Journal of Urban Health, 2023
  4. Illinois and Texas

    Pilot Pilot ended 2020 to 2023

    Researchers randomly assigned people in eighteen Illinois and Texas counties to three years of monthly cash or a lower-payment comparison group.

    3 sources
  5. Cook County, Illinois

    County Pilot ended 2022 to 2025

    The county sent 3,250 households monthly $500 no-strings-attached payments in a two-year pilot that ended with final payments in January 2025.

    Cook County Government, 2025
    • “Launched in 2022, the Cook County Promise Guaranteed Income Pilot was the largest publicly funded program of its kind in the nation. Leveraging $42 million in federal funding provided by the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA), the two-year pilot provided monthly, no-strings-attached payments of $500 to 3,250 households. The final payments were distributed to participants in January 2025.”

      President Preckwinkle Unveils Next Phase of Guaranteed Income in Cook County Cook County Government, 2025 · Government evaluation The county that funded and ran the pilot

What the numbers did

Randomized trial
Who got it was decided at random, so the two groups started out alike.
Compared with similar places
Measured against places or people that did not adopt it.

Work or job-search participation

Went down

The study found labor-market participation, the share working or looking for work, fell by 4.2 percentage points compared with the control group.

2 sources
  • “We study the causal effects of income on a rich array of employment outcomes, leveraging an experiment in which 1,000 low-income individuals were randomized into receiving $1,000 per month unconditionally for three years, with a control group of 2,000 participants receiving $50/month.”

    The Employment Effects of a Guaranteed Income: Experimental Evidence from Two U.S. States Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2026 · Peer-reviewed study

  • “The transfer caused total individual income excluding the transfers to fall by about $1,900/year relative to the control group and a 4.2 percentage point decrease in labor market participation. Participants reduced their work hours as a result of the transfers by 1–2 hours/week and participants’ partners reduced their work hours by a comparable amount.”

    The Employment Effects of a Guaranteed Income: Experimental Evidence from Two U.S. States Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2026 · Peer-reviewed study

Recipients’ paid hours per week

Went down

The study found recipients’ paid hours fell by 1-2 hours/week; their partners’ hours fell by a comparable amount.

2 sources
  • “We study the causal effects of income on a rich array of employment outcomes, leveraging an experiment in which 1,000 low-income individuals were randomized into receiving $1,000 per month unconditionally for three years, with a control group of 2,000 participants receiving $50/month.”

    The Employment Effects of a Guaranteed Income: Experimental Evidence from Two U.S. States Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2026 · Peer-reviewed study

  • “The transfer caused total individual income excluding the transfers to fall by about $1,900/year relative to the control group and a 4.2 percentage point decrease in labor market participation. Participants reduced their work hours as a result of the transfers by 1–2 hours/week and participants’ partners reduced their work hours by a comparable amount.”

    The Employment Effects of a Guaranteed Income: Experimental Evidence from Two U.S. States Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2026 · Peer-reviewed study

Individual income excluding transfers

Went down

The randomized trial found individual income excluding the cash transfers fell by about $1,900/year relative to the control group.

2 sources
  • “We study the causal effects of income on a rich array of employment outcomes, leveraging an experiment in which 1,000 low-income individuals were randomized into receiving $1,000 per month unconditionally for three years, with a control group of 2,000 participants receiving $50/month.”

    The Employment Effects of a Guaranteed Income: Experimental Evidence from Two U.S. States Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2026 · Peer-reviewed study

  • “The transfer caused total individual income excluding the transfers to fall by about $1,900/year relative to the control group and a 4.2 percentage point decrease in labor market participation. Participants reduced their work hours as a result of the transfers by 1–2 hours/week and participants’ partners reduced their work hours by a comparable amount.”

    The Employment Effects of a Guaranteed Income: Experimental Evidence from Two U.S. States Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2026 · Peer-reviewed study

Measured monthly spending

Went up

Recipients increased measured spending by an average of $310 per month, a 7.78 percent increase against the comparison mean.

2 sources

Stress, health and health care use

Mixed

For people getting $1,000 a month, stress and food security improved briefly and hospital, emergency department and dental care use rose; self-reported physical health, biomarkers and mental health did not improve after the first year.

2 sources

Monthly income volatility

Went down

In year one, the treatment group’s income volatility was 19% compared with 26% in control; the paper reports a statistically significant difference.

2 sources

Employment status

No clear change

Employment trends shifted toward the treatment group in the pre-pandemic year but were not statistically significant; follow-up did not detect employment effects.

3 sources

Child development and brain activity

No clear change

In Baby’s First Years, a randomized trial of monthly cash to low-income mothers, the assessment after four years found no statistically significant impact on four preregistered primary outcomes or three secondary outcomes.

Randomized trial
2 sources

Employment and part-time work

Mixed

Jones and Marinescu found no overall employment effect; the dividend increased part-time work by 1.8 percentage points (17 percent).

Compared with similar places Alaska
American Economic Association, 2022

Where the studies disagree

Do unconditional cash payments reduce paid work?

The randomized trial of $1,000 a month found the share working or looking for work fell by 4.2 percentage points and recipients’ paid hours fell by 1-2 hours a week.

3 sources

The Alaska study found no overall employment effect, while part-time work rose by 1.8 percentage points (17 percent).

American Economic Association, 2022

In Stockton’s trial, employment shifts were not statistically significant, and later observation showed no statistically significant effect but a continued trend toward more employment in the treatment group.

3 sources

Why they differ

Alaska paid every resident a yearly dividend and was studied with a synthetic control method; the trials compared payment groups with control groups, 131 against 200 in Stockton and 1,000 against 2,000 in the larger trial.

3 sources

Still open

Who is acting on it now

  1. Enacted

    South Dakota LegislatureState legislature

    The legislature repealed its prohibition on municipal guaranteed-income programs.

    4 sources
    • “BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA:”

      2026 Senate Bill 165 Session Law South Dakota Legislative Research Council, 2026 · Law or ruling

    • “Section 66. That § 9-19-22 be REPEALED. A municipality may not adopt, enforce, or maintain an ordinance, order, or rule for the purpose of making payments to an individual under a guaranteed income program.”

      2026 Senate Bill 165 Session Law South Dakota Legislative Research Council, 2026 · Law or ruling

    • “The bill consolidates sections pertaining to municipal finance officer duties and repeals the prohibition against guaranteed income programs.”

      Title Summary for One Hundred First Session South Dakota Legislative Research Council, 2026 · Law or ruling

    • “required to seek reemployment as a condition of any payments, perform work, or attend training. Signed March 4, 2026”

      2026 Senate Bill 165 Session Law South Dakota Legislative Research Council, 2026 · Law or ruling

  2. Expanded

    New York City CouncilCity legislature

    The Council allocated $1.5 million in Fiscal Year 2025 for a new Bridge Project cohort of 161 pregnant women facing housing insecurity, who receive unconditional income assistance.

    New York City Council, 2024
  3. Blocked

    Texas Supreme CourtState supreme court

    The court prohibited all Uplift Harris payments pending further order while the State’s appeal proceeded.

    2 sources
    • “For the following reasons, the motion is granted, and all payments under the Uplift Harris program are prohibited pending further order of this Court.”

      In re The State of Texas, Relator, No. 24-0325 Supreme Court of Texas, 2024 · Law or ruling

    • “The State's appeal of the denial of a temporary injunction remains pending in the court of appeals, which we expect will proceed expeditiously to a decision.”

      In re The State of Texas, Relator, No. 24-0325 Supreme Court of Texas, 2024 · Law or ruling

  4. Enacted

    Iowa LegislatureState legislature

    Iowa barred counties and cities from starting or extending guaranteed-income programs after the law took effect.

    4 sources
    • “COUNTY AND CITY GUARANTEED INCOME PROGRAMS — PROHIBITION H.F. 2319 AN ACT prohibiting counties and cities from providing guaranteed income programs, and including effective date provisions. Be It Enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Iowa:”

      Chapter 1109: County and City Guaranteed Income Programs Prohibition Iowa Legislature, 2024 · Law or ruling

    • “A guaranteed income program operating prior to or on the effective date of this Act may remain in effect until January 1, 2025, or until expiration of the program, whichever is earlier. A county shall not start a guaranteed income program or extend an existing guaranteed income program after the effective date of this Act.”

      Chapter 1109: County and City Guaranteed Income Programs Prohibition Iowa Legislature, 2024 · Law or ruling

    • “A guaranteed income program operating prior to or on the effective date of this Act may remain in effect until January 1, 2025, or until expiration of the program, whichever is earlier. A city shall not start a guaranteed income program or extend an existing guaranteed income program after the effective date of this Act.”

      Chapter 1109: County and City Guaranteed Income Programs Prohibition Iowa Legislature, 2024 · Law or ruling

    • “EFFECTIVE DATE. This Act, being deemed of immediate importance, takes effect upon enactment. Approved May 1, 2024”

      Chapter 1109: County and City Guaranteed Income Programs Prohibition Iowa Legislature, 2024 · Law or ruling

  5. Blocked

    Texas state appeals courtState appeals court

    The appeals court refused Paxton’s emergency request to stop Harris County from distributing the funds, upholding a lower court’s ruling.

    The Texas Tribune, 2024
  6. Sued

    Ken PaxtonTexas Attorney General

    Paxton sued Harris County to stop its Uplift Harris guaranteed-income program.

    The Texas Tribune, 2024
  7. Enacted

    South Dakota LegislatureState legislature

    The legislature barred counties, townships and municipalities from authorizing guaranteed-income programs.

    2 sources
    • “An Act to prevent a county, township, or municipality from authorizing a guaranteed income program. BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA:”

      2024 Senate Bill 115 South Dakota Legislative Research Council, 2024 · Law or ruling

    • “3/7/2024 Signed by the Governor on March 6, 2024 S.J. 512”

      Index to the Ninety-Ninth Legislative Session South Dakota Legislative Research Council, 2024 · Law or ruling

Sources

Government evaluation1

Peer-reviewed study3

Working paper2

Research organization1

Law or ruling7

Before the next fight over it

See what happened where they tried it.

The brief follows what politicians propose each morning, in their own words, and links the policy pages when one comes up. Free.

Arrives around 6am ET. Free, and it stays that way.

Cancel anytime. Nothing on the site goes behind a paywall.

One payment through Stripe. No account needed.