Unbiasable

Housing First · Housing & rent

Does giving homeless people housing first, with no preconditions, get them off the street?

Housing First offers permanent housing without requiring sobriety or treatment first. Programs can pair a rent supplement with different types of support.

3 sources
  • “Tenant screening and selection practices that promote accepting applicants regardless of their sobriety or use of substances, completion of treatment, or participation in services.”

    SB 1380, Senate Bill, Chaptered California Legislature, 2016 · Law or ruling

  • “The HF program participants in this study were provided with an apartment of their own, a rent supplement, and one of two types of support services: those with high needs received Assertive Community Treatment (ACT) and those with moderate needs received Intensive Case Management (ICM).”

    National At Home/Chez Soi Final Report Mental Health Commission of Canada, 2014 · Government evaluation The commission ran the trial it reports on, with federal funding

  • “Participation in services or program compliance is not a condition of permanent housing tenancy.”

    SB 1380, Senate Bill, Chaptered California Legislature, 2016 · Law or ruling

The answer so far

In Canada’s randomized trial, people spent 73 per cent of their time stably housed over two years against 32 per cent under usual services, while symptoms improved about equally in both groups. In Denver’s trial, people got 560 more days of housing help and made 127 fewer shelter visits over three years, with no clear difference in emergency medical use.

7 sources

Where it was tried

  1. Utah

    State Ended 2005 to 2015

    Utah’s 2005 plan to end chronic homelessness by 2014 centered on a strategy it called Housing First; in 2015 the state said it had largely met the goal.

    3 sources
    • “For example, in 2005, the SHCC announced plans to eliminate chronic homelessness by 2014 and made a commitment to measure the state’s success in achieving that goal.”

      A Performance Audit of Utah’s Homelessness Programs and Services Office of the Utah Legislative Auditor General, 2018 · Government evaluation

    • “The focus of that plan was a strategy they called Housing First.”

      A Performance Audit of Utah’s Homelessness Programs and Services Office of the Utah Legislative Auditor General, 2018 · Government evaluation

    • “In 2015, Utah received national media attention when DWS announced that it had largely achieved its goal to end chronic homelessness. The report states that “Since 2005, the chronic homeless population in Utah has dropped by 91 percent.” However, due to problems with the data, those figures were inaccurate.”

      A Performance Audit of Utah’s Homelessness Programs and Services Office of the Utah Legislative Auditor General, 2018 · Government evaluation

  2. Canada

    Pilot Pilot ended 2008 to 2013

    Canada’s At Home/Chez Soi project ran a five-city randomized trial of Housing First for people experiencing homelessness and serious mental health issues.

    3 sources
    • “In 2008, the federal government invested $110 million for a five-year research demonstration project aimed at generating knowledge about effective approaches for people experiencing serious mental illness and homelessness in Canada.”

      National At Home/Chez Soi Final Report Mental Health Commission of Canada, 2014 · Government evaluation The commission ran the trial it reports on, with federal funding

    • “In response, the Mental Health Commission of Canada (MHCC) and stakeholders in five cities (Vancouver, Winnipeg, Toronto, Montréal and Moncton) implemented a pragmatic randomized controlled field trial of HF (see Appendix A for study design details).”

      National At Home/Chez Soi Final Report Mental Health Commission of Canada, 2014 · Government evaluation The commission ran the trial it reports on, with federal funding

    • “The first participant was enrolled in October 2009 and the last interview ended in June 2013.”

      National At Home/Chez Soi Final Report Mental Health Commission of Canada, 2014 · Government evaluation The commission ran the trial it reports on, with federal funding

  3. Finland

    National Ended 2008 to 2011

    Finland’s PAAVO I program converted homelessness shelters into Housing First units and provided permanent housing with tailored support.

    2 sources
    • “The programme to reduce long-term homelessness (2008–2011) was introduced following a government decision on February 14th 2008.”

      The Finnish Homelessness Strategy: An International Review Ministry of the Environment, Finland, 2015 · Government evaluation

    • “Conversion of homelessness shelters to Housing First units is perhaps the most important achievement of Paavo I. This change enabled long-term homelessness to be halved, with the most vulnerable people in the homeless population gaining permanent housing and tailored support.”

      The Finnish Homelessness Strategy: An International Review Ministry of the Environment, Finland, 2015 · Government evaluation

  4. Finland

    National In force Since 2008

    Finland has used Housing First through homelessness programs since 2008 and established a new long-term homelessness program in 2023.

    3 sources
    • “Since 2008, the Centre's predecessor, Ara, has been involved in long-term homelessness elimination programs in collaboration with municipalities, landlords, and service providers.”

      We are Working to Prevent Homelessness Housing Finance and Development Centre of Finland, 2025 · Official data

    • “Through homelessness programs, Finland began systematically implementing the Housing First approach.”

      We are Working to Prevent Homelessness Housing Finance and Development Centre of Finland, 2025 · Official data

    • “In 2023, a new program to eliminate long-term homelessness was established.”

      We are Working to Prevent Homelessness Housing Finance and Development Centre of Finland, 2025 · Official data

  5. Houston region, Texas

    City In force Since 2012

    Houston’s The Way Home links more than 100 partners running Housing First programs; work on its coordinated system began in 2012.

    2 sources
    • “The work to build Coordinated Access in Houston began in 2012 as part of a community-wide system redesign process.”

      Coordinating Your Way Home in Houston United States Interagency Council on Homelessness, 2017 · News report

    • “Currently, more than 100 partners are collaborating through The Way Home to implement programs that are all based on a Housing First model. This means that people experiencing homelessness are moved into permanent housing as quickly as possible and then are provided with supportive services (like case management, healthcare, substance use counseling, income coaching, and more) to help them remain stabilized in housing and improve their quality of life.”

      The Way Home Coalition for the Homeless, Houston, 2026 · News report Houston's homelessness coalition, describing its own program

  6. Charlotte-Mecklenburg, North Carolina

    County In force Since 2015

    Charlotte-Mecklenburg’s Housing First collaboration focuses on scaling permanent supportive housing for people experiencing chronic homelessness.

    2 sources
  7. California

    State In force Since 2016

    California’s 2016 law requires state agencies that fund homelessness programs, with exceptions, to adopt rules that include Housing First policies, such as accepting tenants regardless of sobriety.

    4 sources
    • “Tenant screening and selection practices that promote accepting applicants regardless of their sobriety or use of substances, completion of treatment, or participation in services.”

      SB 1380, Senate Bill, Chaptered California Legislature, 2016 · Law or ruling

    • “Approved by Governor September 29, 2016. Filed with Secretary of State September 29, 2016.”

      SB 1380, Senate Bill, Chaptered California Legislature, 2016 · Law or ruling

    • “Participation in services or program compliance is not a condition of permanent housing tenancy.”

      SB 1380, Senate Bill, Chaptered California Legislature, 2016 · Law or ruling

    • “This bill would require a state agency or department that funds, implements, or administers a state program that provides housing or housing-related services to people experiencing homelessness or at risk of homelessness, except as specified, to revise or adopt guidelines and regulations to include enumerated Housing First policies.”

      SB 1380, Senate Bill, Chaptered California Legislature, 2016 · Law or ruling

  8. Denver, Colorado

    Pilot Pilot ended 2016 to 2020

    Denver’s pilot paired a housing subsidy with intensive services and randomized 724 people into it or usual care from 2016 to 2020.

    2 sources

What the numbers did

Randomized trial
Who got it was decided at random, so the two groups started out alike.
Compared with similar places
Measured against places or people that did not adopt it.
Official figures over time
No comparison group, so other changes can blur it.

Time in stable housing

Went up

At Home/Chez Soi’s randomized trial found participants spent an average of 73 per cent of their time in stable housing over two years, compared with 32 per cent under usual services.

2 sources
  • “In response, the Mental Health Commission of Canada (MHCC) and stakeholders in five cities (Vancouver, Winnipeg, Toronto, Montréal and Moncton) implemented a pragmatic randomized controlled field trial of HF (see Appendix A for study design details).”

    National At Home/Chez Soi Final Report Mental Health Commission of Canada, 2014 · Government evaluation The commission ran the trial it reports on, with federal funding

  • “Over the two years of the study, participants in HF spent an average of 73 per cent of their time in stable housing compared with 32 per cent in TAU.”

    National At Home/Chez Soi Final Report Mental Health Commission of Canada, 2014 · Government evaluation The commission ran the trial it reports on, with federal funding

Mental health and substance-use symptoms

No clear change

The At Home/Chez Soi trial report said symptom-related outcomes, including substance use problems and mental health symptoms, improved similarly under Housing First and usual services.

2 sources
  • “In response, the Mental Health Commission of Canada (MHCC) and stakeholders in five cities (Vancouver, Winnipeg, Toronto, Montréal and Moncton) implemented a pragmatic randomized controlled field trial of HF (see Appendix A for study design details).”

    National At Home/Chez Soi Final Report Mental Health Commission of Canada, 2014 · Government evaluation The commission ran the trial it reports on, with federal funding

  • “Symptom-related outcomes, including substance use problems and mental health symptoms, improved similarly for both HF and TAU.”

    National At Home/Chez Soi Final Report Mental Health Commission of Canada, 2014 · Government evaluation The commission ran the trial it reports on, with federal funding

Housing assistance days

Went up

The Denver evaluation found people referred to supportive housing received 560 more days of housing assistance over three years than people receiving usual community services.

2 sources

Emergency shelter visits

Went down

Denver’s evaluation found 127 fewer shelter visits over three years among people referred to supportive housing than in the control group, a 40 percent reduction.

2 sources

Jail stays and days

Went down

Denver’s randomized evaluation found that over three years, people referred to supportive housing had almost two fewer jail stays and spent an average of 38 fewer days in jail than those in usual care.

2 sources

Emergency medical services use

No clear change

The Urban Institute found no statistically significant difference between the groups’ use of emergency medical services.

2 sources

Quality-of-life and health measures

Went up

The HFCM evaluation reported improvement over a comparison group on quality of life, mental health, trauma, general health and substance-use measures, including drug or alcohol use to intoxication in the prior 30 days.

2 sources
  • “Housing First Charlotte-Mecklenburg (HFCM) is a multi-sector collaboration to end chronic homelessness by scaling housing first, and particularly the housing first permanent supportive housing model. The effort began in 2015 and the work continues through the Charlotte-Mecklenburg Continuum-of-Care.”

    Housing First Charlotte-Mecklenburg Outcomes & Utilization Report: Frequently Asked Questions UNC Charlotte Urban Institute, 2020 · Research organization

  • “The study measured people’s quality of life, mental health symptoms, trauma symptoms, perceived general health and mental health, and substance use using standardized measures. Participants improved on all measures beyond that of the comparison group, including use of any drug and/or alcohol to the point of intoxication in the last 30 days.”

    Housing First Charlotte-Mecklenburg Outcomes & Utilization Report: Frequently Asked Questions UNC Charlotte Urban Institute, 2020 · Research organization

Long-term homelessness count

Went down

An international review published by Finland’s Ministry of the Environment reported a 28% decline in long-term homelessness during PAAVO I, from 2008 to 2011.

Official figures over time Finland
Ministry of the Environment, Finland, 2015

Homeless people living alone

Went up

Varke reported 4,579 homeless people living alone in Finland in 2025, 773 more than the year before.

Official figures over time Finland
Housing Finance and Development Centre of Finland, 2026
  • “In 2025 in Finland there were 4,579 homeless people living alone, which is 773 more than in the year before.”

    Homeless people 2025 Housing Finance and Development Centre of Finland, 2026 · Official data

Where the studies disagree

Did Utah’s chronic homeless count really fall 91 percent?

In 2015, Utah’s Department of Workforce Services announced the state had largely met its goal, reporting a 91 percent drop in chronic homelessness since 2005.

Office of the Utah Legislative Auditor General, 2018
  • “In 2015, Utah received national media attention when DWS announced that it had largely achieved its goal to end chronic homelessness. The report states that “Since 2005, the chronic homeless population in Utah has dropped by 91 percent.” However, due to problems with the data, those figures were inaccurate.”

    A Performance Audit of Utah’s Homelessness Programs and Services Office of the Utah Legislative Auditor General, 2018 · Government evaluation

Utah’s legislative auditor later said problems with the data made those figures inaccurate.

Office of the Utah Legislative Auditor General, 2018
  • “In 2015, Utah received national media attention when DWS announced that it had largely achieved its goal to end chronic homelessness. The report states that “Since 2005, the chronic homeless population in Utah has dropped by 91 percent.” However, due to problems with the data, those figures were inaccurate.”

    A Performance Audit of Utah’s Homelessness Programs and Services Office of the Utah Legislative Auditor General, 2018 · Government evaluation

Why they differ

The 2015 figure was a raw one-night count, while earlier years were annualized estimates made with a method that changed; in 2015 the local Continuum of Care also changed how it verified chronic homelessness.

2 sources
  • “As stated in the legend of Figure 2.2, the 2015 number is the raw data from the Point-in-Time count, while the previous years are annualized numbers. The annualized number are the point-in-time count multiplied by some factor. In addition, the method for annualizing the count has changed.”

    A Performance Audit of Utah’s Homelessness Programs and Services Office of the Utah Legislative Auditor General, 2018 · Government evaluation

  • “In 2015, the COC reported that it adopted a new process for verifying whether an individual is chronically homeless.”

    A Performance Audit of Utah’s Homelessness Programs and Services Office of the Utah Legislative Auditor General, 2018 · Government evaluation

Still open

Who is acting on it now

  1. Blocked

    U.S. Court of Appeals for the First CircuitFederal appeals court

    The First Circuit granted HUD an emergency stay of the district court’s ruling while HUD appeals.

    U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, 2026
    • “On Wednesday, September 16, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit granted HUD an emergency stay pending appeal”

      Continuum of Care Program Competition U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, 2026 · News report

  2. Blocked

    U.S. District Court for the District of Rhode IslandFederal trial court

    In suits brought by the State of Washington, the National Alliance to End Homelessness and others, the court set aside HUD’s 2026 funding notice but denied a permanent injunction.

    2 sources
    • “The Court therefore sets aside HUD’s issuance of the 2026 NOFO in its entirety as violative of the APA. The Court, however, denies Plaintiffs’ request for a permanent injunction.”

      Memorandum and Order on Summary Judgment in National Alliance to End Homelessness v. HUD U.S. District Court for the District of Rhode Island, 2026 · Law or ruling

    • “State of Washington, et al. v. HUD, et al., 1:26-cv-00439 (D.R.I.), and National Alliance to End Homelessness, et al. v. HUD, et al., 1:26-cv-00436 (D.R.I.).”

      Continuum of Care Program Competition U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, 2026 · News report

  3. Enacted

    U.S. Department of Housing and Urban DevelopmentFederal housing agency

    HUD announced $3.9 billion in Continuum of Care grants under a notice it said redirects funding to transitional housing and supportive services.

    2 sources
  4. Enacted

    President Donald TrumpPresident of the United States

    The order directed agencies, to the extent permitted by law, to end support for Housing First policies and told HUD to take steps to require treatment as a condition of some assistance.

    2 sources
    • “These actions shall include, to the extent permitted by law, ending support for “housing first” policies that deprioritize accountability and fail to promote treatment, recovery, and self-sufficiency; increasing competition among grantees through broadening the applicant pool; and holding grantees to higher standards of effectiveness in reducing homelessness and increasing public safety.”

      Ending Crime and Disorder on America’s Streets The White House, 2025 · Law or ruling

    • “The Secretary of Housing and Urban Development shall, as appropriate, take steps to require recipients of Federal housing and homelessness assistance to increase requirements that persons participating in the recipients’ programs who suffer from substance use disorder or serious mental illness use substance abuse treatment or mental health services as a condition of participation.”

      Ending Crime and Disorder on America’s Streets The White House, 2025 · Law or ruling

Sources

Official data2

Government evaluation3

Law or ruling3

News report5

Before the next fight over it

See what happened where they tried it.

The brief follows what politicians propose each morning, in their own words, and links the policy pages when one comes up. Free.

Arrives around 6am ET. Free, and it stays that way.

Cancel anytime. Nothing on the site goes behind a paywall.

One payment through Stripe. No account needed.