The ACA expansion lets states cover nearly all adults with incomes up to 138% of the federal poverty level and provides an enhanced federal match. States adopted it through legislation or ballot measures; Arkansas used a private-option design that enrolled expansion adults in Marketplace plans.
¶3 sources
“The Affordable Care Act’s (ACA) Medicaid expansion expanded Medicaid coverage to nearly all adults with incomes up to 138% of the Federal Poverty Level ($21,597 for an individual in 2025) and provided states with an enhanced federal matching rate (FMAP) for their expansion populations.”
“The approach, often referred to as the “private option,” was designed by the state with goals of increasing access to care by placing beneficiaries in private health plans with a robust provider network; reducing the effects of churning as enrollees move between Medicaid and Marketplace coverage as their income fluctuates; and reinforcing the state’s broader health care delivery system reform efforts.”
Expansion states had lower uninsured rates than other states at every income level, the Census Bureau reports. Oregon’s randomized lottery found Medicaid cut medical bills sent to collections by 6.4 percentage points and depression by 9 points, raised emergency visits by 0.41 per person, and had no clear effect on blood pressure or cholesterol. Federal Medicaid spending rose about 38 percent after expansion’s first year.
¶6 sources
“Uninsured rates were lower for all income-to-poverty groups in expansion states than in nonexpansion states.”
“Medicaid diminished financial hardship. Medicaid reduced the likelihood of having any unpaid medical bills that were sent to collection agencies by 6.4 percentage points (a 23 percent decrease). It also reduced several other measures of financial hardship such as having any medical debt at the time of the interview and having to borrow money or skip paying bills in the past year to pay for medical bills.”
“Medicaid reduced rates of depression by 9 percentage points (a 31 percent decrease) and increased the likelihood of self-reporting health as good, very good, or excellent (as opposed to fair or poor) by 13 percentage points (a 24 percent increase).”
“We found that Medicaid coverage significantly increases overall emergency use by 0.41 visits per person, or 40% relative to an average of 1.02 visits per person in the control group.”
“Medicaid reduced rates of depression and improved self-reported health, but had no statistically significant effect on physical health measures. Specifically, Medicaid did not have a statistically significant effect on measured blood pressure, cholesterol, or glycated hemoglobin (a measure of diabetes).”
“Excluding the first state fiscal year of expansion (which was half preexpansion and half postexpansion), Medicaid expansion increases total Medicaid spending by approximately 23 percent and federal Medicaid spending by approximately 38 percent, but it does not increase state Medicaid spending (at least not through the first five-and-a-half years).”
20sources, 5 of them government data, government reviews or journals
Where it was tried
Oregon Health Insurance Experiment
PilotEnded2008 to 2008
In 2008, Oregon used a lottery to fill a limited number of Medicaid slots for low-income, uninsured adults, letting researchers compare those selected with those who were not.
¶3 sources
“In 2008, a group of uninsured low-income adults in Oregon was selected by lottery to be given the chance to apply for Medicaid.”
“In 2008, the state of Oregon decided that the OHP Standard program could accommodate 10,000 new enrollees. Oregon state health officials correctly anticipated that the demand for OHP Standard would far exceed the number of slots available and decided that a lottery was the fairest way to allocate these scarce slots.”
Arkansas covered expansion adults through Marketplace plans under its Private Option, which state lawmakers voted to replace with Arkansas Works.
¶4 sources
“Arkansas’ “private option” approach to Medicaid expansion has undergone multiple modifications since initial implementation in 2014, as a result of decisions during the reauthorization process, requirements in the original expansion legislation, and a gubernatorial transition in 2015 when Republican Governor Hutchinson succeeded former Democratic Governor Beebe.”
“Stakeholder interviews revealed that the private option offers a path to coverage for close to 260,000 newly eligible adults in Arkansas, and enabled the state to use Marketplace plans to cover Medicaid beneficiaries in the absence of an established Medicaid managed care delivery system in the state.”
“In response, the legislature extended funding for the private option through 2016 when the initiative is slated to sunset, and created the Legislative Health Reform Task Force, which will make recommendations by December 2015 for modernizing the state’s overall Medicaid program.”
“Arkansas Works would replace the program currently referred to as the Private Option which uses federal Medicaid funding to provide private insurance plans for the state’s lowest income residents.”
States began adopting the ACA Medicaid expansion in 2014, with additional states implementing it later.
¶2 sources
“Over half (27) of states adopted Medicaid expansion in 2014, while 14 states have implemented expansion since 2014, with South Dakota and North Carolina adopting most recently in 2023.”
Who got it was decided at random, so the two groups started out alike.
Compared with similar places
Measured against places or people that did not adopt it.
Official figures over time
No comparison group, so other changes can blur it.
Emergency department visits per person
↑Went up
Using Portland-area hospital records, the randomized Oregon study found Medicaid coverage increased emergency use by 0.41 visits per person, or 40% relative to the control group’s 1.02 visits.
¶2 sources
“By using the randomization provided by the lottery and emergency-department records from Portland-area hospitals, we studied the emergency department use of about 25,000 lottery participants over about 18 months after the lottery.”
“We found that Medicaid coverage significantly increases overall emergency use by 0.41 visits per person, or 40% relative to an average of 1.02 visits per person in the control group.”
The Oregon lottery found Medicaid reduced the likelihood of an unpaid medical bill going to collections by 6.4 percentage points.
¶Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab, 2013
“Medicaid diminished financial hardship. Medicaid reduced the likelihood of having any unpaid medical bills that were sent to collection agencies by 6.4 percentage points (a 23 percent decrease). It also reduced several other measures of financial hardship such as having any medical debt at the time of the interview and having to borrow money or skip paying bills in the past year to pay for medical bills.”
The Oregon lottery estimated that Medicaid reduced depression rates by 9 percentage points.
¶Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab, 2013
“Medicaid reduced rates of depression by 9 percentage points (a 31 percent decrease) and increased the likelihood of self-reporting health as good, very good, or excellent (as opposed to fair or poor) by 13 percentage points (a 24 percent increase).”
The Oregon randomized study found no statistically significant effect on measured blood pressure, cholesterol, or glycated hemoglobin, a blood-sugar measure of diabetes.
¶Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab, 2013
“Medicaid reduced rates of depression and improved self-reported health, but had no statistically significant effect on physical health measures. Specifically, Medicaid did not have a statistically significant effect on measured blood pressure, cholesterol, or glycated hemoglobin (a measure of diabetes).”
Annual mortality among adults nearing Medicare age
↓Went down
Miller, Altekruse, Johnson and Wherry found annual mortality among near-elderly adults in expansion states fell 0.132 percentage point, a 9.4 percent reduction, in association with Medicaid expansion.
¶2 sources
“Our analysis compares changes in mortality for near-elderly adults in states with and without Affordable Care Act Medicaid expansions.”
A KFF review found some studies reported no expansion-related changes in employment rates, job switches, or transitions from full-time to part-time work.
¶KFF, 2020
“Measures in this area that showed no changes related to expansion in some studies include measures of employment rates, transitions from employment to non-employment, the rate of job switches, transitions from full- to part-time employment, labor force participation, usual hours worked per week, self-employment, and Supplemental Security Income applications.”
Excluding expansion’s first fiscal year, a Commonwealth Fund analysis found total Medicaid spending rose about 23 percent and federal spending about 38 percent, while state Medicaid spending did not rise.
¶The Commonwealth Fund, 2020
“Excluding the first state fiscal year of expansion (which was half preexpansion and half postexpansion), Medicaid expansion increases total Medicaid spending by approximately 23 percent and federal Medicaid spending by approximately 38 percent, but it does not increase state Medicaid spending (at least not through the first five-and-a-half years).”
Using hospital data for 2008-16, a Health Affairs study linked expansion with improved hospital financial performance, especially in rural markets.
¶Health Affairs, 2018
“We tested this hypothesis using data for the period 2008–16 on hospital closures and financial performance. We found that the ACA’s Medicaid expansion was associated with improved hospital financial performance and substantially lower likelihoods of closure, especially in rural markets and counties with large numbers of uninsured adults before Medicaid expansion.”
Using hospital data for 2008-16, a Health Affairs study linked expansion with lower likelihoods of hospital closure, especially in rural markets.
¶Health Affairs, 2018
“We tested this hypothesis using data for the period 2008–16 on hospital closures and financial performance. We found that the ACA’s Medicaid expansion was associated with improved hospital financial performance and substantially lower likelihoods of closure, especially in rural markets and counties with large numbers of uninsured adults before Medicaid expansion.”
Operating margin (operating income relative to revenue), staffing, quality
→No clear change
A national study found no statistically significant differential improvements in operating margins, staffing levels, or quality at critical access hospitals in expansion states compared with nonexpansion states.
¶Health Affairs, 2021
“However, in this national study we found no evidence that critical access hospitals in Medicaid expansion states nationwide experienced statistically significant differential improvements in operating margins, staffing levels, or quality compared with those in nonexpansion states.”
Below the poverty line, the uninsured rate rose 0.7 points to 16.4 percent in expansion states and 1.7 points to 36.4 percent in nonexpansion states, the Census Bureau found.
¶2 sources
“For people living below the poverty line, the uninsured rate increased by 0.7 percentage points in expansion states to 16.4 percent, and 1.7 percentage points in nonexpansion states to 36.4 percent.”
Why do health studies report different Medicaid effects?
A
The Oregon lottery found no statistically significant effect on blood pressure, cholesterol, or glycated hemoglobin, a blood-sugar measure of diabetes.
¶Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab, 2013
“Medicaid reduced rates of depression and improved self-reported health, but had no statistically significant effect on physical health measures. Specifically, Medicaid did not have a statistically significant effect on measured blood pressure, cholesterol, or glycated hemoglobin (a measure of diabetes).”
A study of near-elderly adults found a 0.132 percentage point decline in annual mortality, a 9.4 percent reduction, associated with Medicaid expansion.
¶2 sources
“Our analysis compares changes in mortality for near-elderly adults in states with and without Affordable Care Act Medicaid expansions.”
The Oregon lottery measured physical markers among lottery participants over an approximately two-year study window, while the mortality analysis compared near-elderly adults in expansion and nonexpansion states. The studies measured different outcomes in different populations with different designs.
¶3 sources
“In 2008, a group of uninsured low-income adults in Oregon was selected by lottery to be given the chance to apply for Medicaid.”
“Researchers used a combination of administrative data sources, in-person interviews, and mail surveys to collect information on earnings, financial hardship, health-care use, insurance coverage, medical history, and physical health, over an approximately two-year period after the lottery.”
Did expansion improve hospital finances and keep hospitals open?
A
A study using hospital data from 2008-16 associated expansion with improved financial performance and a lower likelihood of closure, especially in rural markets.
¶Health Affairs, 2018
“We tested this hypothesis using data for the period 2008–16 on hospital closures and financial performance. We found that the ACA’s Medicaid expansion was associated with improved hospital financial performance and substantially lower likelihoods of closure, especially in rural markets and counties with large numbers of uninsured adults before Medicaid expansion.”
A study of critical access hospitals found no statistically significant differential improvement in margins, staffing, or quality after expansion.
¶Health Affairs, 2021
“However, in this national study we found no evidence that critical access hospitals in Medicaid expansion states nationwide experienced statistically significant differential improvements in operating margins, staffing levels, or quality compared with those in nonexpansion states.”
The studies examined different hospital groups and outcomes. One assessed financial performance and closure across hospitals, with results for rural markets; the other focused on critical access hospitals and measured margins, staffing, and quality.
¶2 sources
“We tested this hypothesis using data for the period 2008–16 on hospital closures and financial performance. We found that the ACA’s Medicaid expansion was associated with improved hospital financial performance and substantially lower likelihoods of closure, especially in rural markets and counties with large numbers of uninsured adults before Medicaid expansion.”
“However, in this national study we found no evidence that critical access hospitals in Medicaid expansion states nationwide experienced statistically significant differential improvements in operating margins, staffing levels, or quality compared with those in nonexpansion states.”
Why did Oregon emergency-use estimates differ by data source?
A
Oregon administrative records showed Medicaid coverage increased emergency department visits by 0.41 per person.
¶Science, 2014
“We found that Medicaid coverage significantly increases overall emergency use by 0.41 visits per person, or 40% relative to an average of 1.02 visits per person in the control group.”
Participant self-reports showed no statistically significant change in emergency department use.
¶Science, 2014
“In contrast to the results from administrative records, neither set of self-reports produced statistically significant changes in emergency-department use.”
The administrative records covered a longer period, and the survey data were limited to people who answered; the authors say administrative data may have less misclassification.
¶2 sources
“Second, the study populations were different; in particular, the self-reported data were by necessity limited to individuals who respond to the surveys or complete the interviews.”
“These results highlight important advantages of administrative data. Even for outcomes that can be self-reported, the emergency-department administrative data are able to capture a longer period and may have less misclassification, allowing for more precise estimates.”
Longer-term effects on blood pressure, cholesterol, and diabetes markers beyond the Oregon trial period remain unsettled.
The net state budget effect varies across states and has not been measured uniformly.
The enrollment and health effects of the new community-engagement requirements are not yet observable.
Who is acting on it now
Voted against
South Dakota votersElectorate
Initial results showed South Dakota voters rejecting Amendment I, which would have ended Medicaid expansion if federal funding fell below 90%.
¶2 sources
“Initial reporting from the South Dakota Secretary of State's website shows voters rejecting an amendment that would end Medicaid expansion, contingent on a lapse in federal funding.”
“But the state’s Republican attorney general, Marty Jackley, said the amendment would automatically repeal Medicaid expansion if federal funding falls below that level. It’s his responsibility to write the ballot language, and the title he wrote says the amendment “repeals expanded Medicaid coverage” if federal funding drops below 90%, while the explanation he wrote says if that scenario occurs, the amendment “ends the expanded Medicaid coverage.””
Congress enacted Public Law 119-21 on July 4, 2025; it added community-engagement requirements for certain individuals under Medicaid.
¶2 sources
“The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) is providing additional guidance outlining how states should implement landmark community engagement requirements created by the Working Families Tax Cut (WFTC) legislation (Public Law 119-21).”
“Earlier this year, legislators decided to put Amendment F on the ballot. The amendment will allow lawmakers to consider a work requirement if the federal government permits it.”