Unbiasable

Drug decriminalization · Guns, crime & policing

When places stopped arresting people for drug possession, what happened to overdoses?

Drug decriminalization removes or reduces criminal penalties for possession for personal use, though some places still route cases through administrative systems or apply fines. Some versions also pair the change with treatment and harm-reduction funding.

4 sources
  • “According to article 2(1) of Law No. 30/2000, the use, acquisition, and possession of plants, substances, or preparations listed in the abovementioned tables for a person’s own consumption constitute misdemeanors (contra-ordenaçãos).”

    Decriminalization of Narcotics: Portugal Law Library of Congress, 2016 · Law or ruling

  • “In November 2020, in the most sweeping response to date, Oregon voters passed Measure 110 (M110), making it the first state to de jure decriminalize the possession of all nonprescribed drugs for personal use, while reallocating millions of dollars toward addiction treatment, recovery programs, housing, and harm reduction services.¹¹”

    Drug Decriminalization, Fentanyl, and Fatal Overdoses in Oregon JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024 · Peer-reviewed study

  • “Portugal decriminalised use, replacing criminal sanctions by administrative penalties by Law 30/2000 of 29 November 2000 (which entered into force in July 2001).”

    Drug Policy and Human Rights Council of Europe, 2017 · Government evaluation

  • “Czech Regulation No. 467/2009 (which came into force on 1 January 2010) clarified the maximum amounts for possession to be treated as a misdemeanour punished by fine, effectively decriminalising possession of small amounts of drugs for own consumption.”

    Drug Policy and Human Rights Council of Europe, 2017 · Government evaluation

The answer so far

In Oregon, one study estimated 182 more unintentional overdose deaths in 2021, two found no evidence of a link to higher fatal overdose rates, and a working paper estimated about 1,186 excess deaths. In British Columbia’s first 11 months, unregulated drug deaths showed no statistically significant change. A Portugal study estimated fewer drug-related deaths, a measure Portugal defines broadly.

7 sources
  • “Spencer concluded that M110 “caused 182 additional unintentional drug overdose deaths to occur in Oregon in 2021,”¹⁸(p1) representing a 23% increase.”

    Drug Decriminalization, Fentanyl, and Fatal Overdoses in Oregon JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024 · Peer-reviewed study

  • “This study found no evidence of an association between legal changes that removed or substantially reduced criminal penalties for drug possession in Oregon and Washington and fatal drug overdose rates.”

    One-Year Association of Drug Possession Law Change With Fatal Drug Overdose in Oregon and Washington JAMA Psychiatry (full article copy hosted by the Oregon Legislative Information System), 2023 · Peer-reviewed study

  • “In this cohort study of fatal overdose and fentanyl spread through Oregon’s unregulated drug market, decriminalization of drug possession was not associated with an increase in fatal drug overdose rates in Oregon in the 2 years after its enactment.”

    Drug Decriminalization, Fentanyl, and Fatal Overdoses in Oregon JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024 · Peer-reviewed study

  • “Synthetic-control estimates show that both policies sharply reduced drug arrests and were followed by sustained increases in overdose mortality relative to matched counterfactuals. The estimates imply approximately 1,186 excess deaths in Oregon and 1,895 in Washington from 2021 through 2023.”

    Did Decriminalization Increase Overdoses? Author page, NBER Working Paper No. 35427, 2026 · Working paper

  • “In the first 11 months of decriminalization, there was no statistically significant change in the rate of unregulated drug deaths or paramedic-attended opioid overdoses, according to a study published in the journal Drug and Alcohol Review in 2025.”

    Decriminalization in B.C. British Columbia Centre for Disease Control, 2026 · Official data British Columbia's public health agency

  • “The results suggest that a policy change implemented in Portugal contributed to a decrease in the number of heroine and cocaine seizures, a decrease in the number of offenses and drug-related deaths, and a decrease in the number of clients entering treatment.”

    Going after the Addiction, Not the Addicted: The Impact of Drug Decriminalization in Portugal IZA Institute of Labor Economics, 2017 · Working paper

  • “However, one must be careful when analyzing the Portuguese trend because the Portuguese definition of drug-related deaths is broader than that of most European countries: it contemplates all autopsies testing positive for toxicological examinations, while for most European countries national definitions are stricter, accounting only for overdoses.”

    Going after the Addiction, Not the Addicted: The Impact of Drug Decriminalization in Portugal IZA Institute of Labor Economics, 2017 · Working paper

Where it was tried

  1. Portugal

    National In force Since Jul 1, 2001

    Portugal moved personal acquisition, possession and use from criminal sanctions to administrative penalties.

    3 sources
    • “According to article 2(1) of Law No. 30/2000, the use, acquisition, and possession of plants, substances, or preparations listed in the abovementioned tables for a person’s own consumption constitute misdemeanors (contra-ordenaçãos).”

      Decriminalization of Narcotics: Portugal Law Library of Congress, 2016 · Law or ruling

    • “Portugal decriminalised use, replacing criminal sanctions by administrative penalties by Law 30/2000 of 29 November 2000 (which entered into force in July 2001).”

      Drug Policy and Human Rights Council of Europe, 2017 · Government evaluation

    • “Secondly, it should be noted that Law No. 30/2000 of 29 November decriminalised drug consumption, prohibiting it as a mere administrative offence and maintaining criminalisation only for the cultivation of narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances (see Article 28).”

      Summary 347/2025 Constitutional Court of Portugal, 2025 · Law or ruling

  2. Czechia

    National In force Since 2010

    Czechia treats small personal-use quantities as minor offences; cannabis has separate limits and rules from 2026.

    3 sources
    • “Czech Regulation No. 467/2009 (which came into force on 1 January 2010) clarified the maximum amounts for possession to be treated as a misdemeanour punished by fine, effectively decriminalising possession of small amounts of drugs for own consumption.”

      Drug Policy and Human Rights Council of Europe, 2017 · Government evaluation

    • “Decriminalization in the Czech Republic means that less serious act such as possession of a narcotic or psychotropic substance for personal use, or cultivation of plants or mushrooms containing a narcotic or psychotropic substance for personal use is classified as a minor offence (misdemeanour) with no criminal sanctions.”

      Legal Framework of Illicit Drugs in the Czech Republic Government of the Czech Republic, 2022 · Government evaluation

    • “Specifická situace nastala od roku 2026 také u konopí a některých psychomodulačních látek, kde legislativa nově stanovuje odlišné limity a pravidla posuzování.”

      Právní minimum Police of the Czech Republic, 2026 · Law or ruling

  3. Oregon

    State Repealed Feb 1, 2021 to Sep 1, 2024

    Oregon voters removed criminal penalties for most small-quantity possession, making it a fine-only violation before lawmakers restored misdemeanor penalties.

    2 sources
    • “In November 2020, in the most sweeping response to date, Oregon voters passed Measure 110 (M110), making it the first state to de jure decriminalize the possession of all nonprescribed drugs for personal use, while reallocating millions of dollars toward addiction treatment, recovery programs, housing, and harm reduction services.¹¹”

      Drug Decriminalization, Fentanyl, and Fatal Overdoses in Oregon JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024 · Peer-reviewed study

    • “Measure 110 reduced penalties for most PCS offenses from a crime to a new Class E violation, punishable with a $100 maximum fine. Effective February 1, 2021, most PCS offenses are punishable only by a fine – no jail, supervision, or other criminal penalties can be imposed. PCS offenses were re-criminalized by 2024 HB 4002, effective September 1, 2024.”

      Measure 110 Statistics Oregon Judicial Department, 2024 · Law or ruling

  4. Washington State

    State Ended Feb 25, 2021 to Jul 25, 2021

    The state Supreme Court struck down the simple-possession law, briefly ending criminal penalties for possession.

    JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024
    • “Following previous studies,18,19 we did not include Washington State in the comparison group because its supreme court effectively decriminalized drug possession for 4 months between February 25 (when it struck down the state's drug possession law) and July 25, 2021”

      Drug Decriminalization, Fentanyl, and Fatal Overdoses in Oregon JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024 · Peer-reviewed study

  5. British Columbia

    Pilot Pilot ended Jan 31, 2023 to Jan 31, 2026

    A federal exemption let adults possess small amounts of specified drugs for personal use; officials later limited the places covered before the pilot expired.

    4 sources
    • “On January 31, 2023, an exemption to the federal Controlled Drugs and Substances Act came into effect in British Columbia as a three-year pilot removing criminal penalties for the possession of small amounts of some illicit substances for personal use by people over 18 years old.”

      Decriminalization in B.C. British Columbia Centre for Disease Control, 2026 · Official data British Columbia's public health agency

    • “The decriminalization exemption expired on January 31, 2026, and will not be renewed, making possession of any amount of illicit substances illegal and enforceable anywhere that does not have an exemption such as supervised consumption and drug checking sites.”

      Decriminalization in B.C. British Columbia Centre for Disease Control, 2026 · Official data British Columbia's public health agency

    • “On May 7, 2024, due to concerns about substance use in public settings and at the request of BC, Health Canada replaced the exemption with a new s.56 exemption which decriminalizes possession of small amounts of illegal drugs only in specific locations, including:”

      Decriminalization: Data Report to Health Canada, February 2023 to July 2024 Government of British Columbia, 2024 · Government evaluation The provincial government reporting on its own pilot

    • “The intention of the new exemption is to balance goals of public health, public safety, and other community interests by prohibiting the possession (a pre-condition to use) of illegal drugs in public spaces, and reinstating police authority to address problematic substance use in public spaces with a possession offense.”

      Decriminalization: Data Report to Health Canada, February 2023 to July 2024 Government of British Columbia, 2024 · Government evaluation The provincial government reporting on its own pilot

What the numbers did

Compared with similar places
Measured against places or people that did not adopt it.
Before and after
The same place before and after; other changes at the time can blur it.
Official figures over time
No comparison group, so other changes can blur it.

Unintentional drug overdose deaths

Went up

Spencer estimated 182 additional unintentional overdose deaths in Oregon in 2021, representing a 23% increase.

Compared with similar places Oregon
JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024
  • “Spencer concluded that M110 “caused 182 additional unintentional drug overdose deaths to occur in Oregon in 2021,”¹⁸(p1) representing a 23% increase.”

    Drug Decriminalization, Fentanyl, and Fatal Overdoses in Oregon JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024 · Peer-reviewed study

Fatal drug overdose rates

No clear change

Joshi and colleagues found no evidence of an association between Oregon’s and Washington’s legal changes and fatal drug overdose rates.

Compared with similar places
3 sources

Fatal drug overdose rates

No clear change

Zoorob and colleagues found decriminalization was not associated with an increase in Oregon fatal overdose rates in the 2 years after enactment, while accounting for the spread of fentanyl.

Compared with similar places Oregon
2 sources
  • “In this cohort study of fatal overdose and fentanyl spread through Oregon’s unregulated drug market, decriminalization of drug possession was not associated with an increase in fatal drug overdose rates in Oregon in the 2 years after its enactment.”

    Drug Decriminalization, Fentanyl, and Fatal Overdoses in Oregon JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024 · Peer-reviewed study

  • “while accounting for the state's rapid spread of fentanyl in its unregulated drug market as a time-varying covariate.”

    Drug Decriminalization, Fentanyl, and Fatal Overdoses in Oregon JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024 · Peer-reviewed study

Overdose deaths

Went up

Hall, Hansen and Matsuzawa’s working paper estimates approximately 1,186 excess deaths in Oregon and 1,895 in Washington from 2021 through 2023 compared with its matched states.

Compared with similar places
Author page, NBER Working Paper No. 35427, 2026
  • “Synthetic-control estimates show that both policies sharply reduced drug arrests and were followed by sustained increases in overdose mortality relative to matched counterfactuals. The estimates imply approximately 1,186 excess deaths in Oregon and 1,895 in Washington from 2021 through 2023.”

    Did Decriminalization Increase Overdoses? Author page, NBER Working Paper No. 35427, 2026 · Working paper

Possession and other arrests

Mixed

Davis and colleagues found 3 fewer drug possession arrests per 100,000 in Oregon and almost 5 fewer in Washington in the month after each state’s 2021 policy change. They found no statistically significant changes in overall, non-drug or violent-crime arrests relative to controls.

Compared with similar places
5 sources

Drug-related deaths

Went down

An IZA study estimated Portugal’s drug-related deaths fell after its 2001 decriminalization; its authors note Portugal counts every autopsy testing positive, while most European countries count only overdoses.

4 sources

Hospitalizations and overdose deaths

Mixed

Nguyen and colleagues found adding decriminalization to safer supply was associated with 1.27 more opioid hospitalizations per 100 000 people, an overall 58% increase on the period before safer supply.

4 sources

Overdose deaths and paramedic calls

No clear change

A 2025 study cited by BCCDC found no statistically significant change in unregulated drug deaths or paramedic-attended opioid overdoses in the first 11 months of decriminalization.

2 sources
  • “In the first 11 months of decriminalization, there was no statistically significant change in the rate of unregulated drug deaths or paramedic-attended opioid overdoses, according to a study published in the journal Drug and Alcohol Review in 2025.”

    Decriminalization in B.C. British Columbia Centre for Disease Control, 2026 · Official data British Columbia's public health agency

  • “On January 31, 2023, an exemption to the federal Controlled Drugs and Substances Act came into effect in British Columbia as a three-year pilot removing criminal penalties for the possession of small amounts of some illicit substances for personal use by people over 18 years old.”

    Decriminalization in B.C. British Columbia Centre for Disease Control, 2026 · Official data British Columbia's public health agency

Drug possession seizures

Mixed

CIHR’s evaluation found seizures below 2.5g fell 87% and seizures in any quantity fell 68% during the initial period, then returned to pre-decriminalization levels after the May 2024 amendment.

Canadian Institutes of Health Research, 2026

Monthly possession offences

Went up

BCCDC data show monthly possession offences rose to approximately 79% of the pre-exemption level recorded in 2022 after the May 7, 2024 revision.

British Columbia Centre for Disease Control, 2026
  • “Since the new exemption came into effect on May 7, 2024, the average number of monthly possession offences has increased to approximately 79% of the pre-exemption level (2022).”

    Decriminalization in B.C. British Columbia Centre for Disease Control, 2026 · Official data British Columbia's public health agency

Treatment provider encounters

Went up

OHA, which funds the program, said providers reported 159,000 encounters for substance use treatment and more than 149,000 for harm reduction in its first full year, from July 1, 2022.

Official figures over time Oregon
Oregon Health Authority, 2024

Where the studies disagree

Did decriminalization increase overdose deaths?

Spencer estimated 182 additional unintentional overdose deaths in Oregon in 2021, representing a 23% increase.

JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024
  • “Spencer concluded that M110 “caused 182 additional unintentional drug overdose deaths to occur in Oregon in 2021,”¹⁸(p1) representing a 23% increase.”

    Drug Decriminalization, Fentanyl, and Fatal Overdoses in Oregon JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024 · Peer-reviewed study

Joshi and colleagues found no evidence of an association between Oregon’s and Washington’s legal changes and fatal drug overdose rates.

3 sources

Zoorob and colleagues reported decriminalization was not associated with an increase in Oregon fatal overdose rates over 2 years, accounting for fentanyl’s spread.

2 sources
  • “In this cohort study of fatal overdose and fentanyl spread through Oregon’s unregulated drug market, decriminalization of drug possession was not associated with an increase in fatal drug overdose rates in Oregon in the 2 years after its enactment.”

    Drug Decriminalization, Fentanyl, and Fatal Overdoses in Oregon JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024 · Peer-reviewed study

  • “while accounting for the state's rapid spread of fentanyl in its unregulated drug market as a time-varying covariate.”

    Drug Decriminalization, Fentanyl, and Fatal Overdoses in Oregon JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024 · Peer-reviewed study

Hall, Hansen and Matsuzawa estimate approximately 1,186 excess deaths in Oregon and 1,895 in Washington from 2021 through 2023.

Author page, NBER Working Paper No. 35427, 2026
  • “Synthetic-control estimates show that both policies sharply reduced drug arrests and were followed by sustained increases in overdose mortality relative to matched counterfactuals. The estimates imply approximately 1,186 excess deaths in Oregon and 1,895 in Washington from 2021 through 2023.”

    Did Decriminalization Increase Overdoses? Author page, NBER Working Paper No. 35427, 2026 · Working paper

Why they differ

They differ in outcome, period and method: Spencer looks at 2021 deaths, Zoorob at 2 years with fentanyl as a covariate, and Hall’s estimates through 2023 stay positive under other fentanyl measures.

5 sources
  • “Spencer concluded that M110 “caused 182 additional unintentional drug overdose deaths to occur in Oregon in 2021,”¹⁸(p1) representing a 23% increase.”

    Drug Decriminalization, Fentanyl, and Fatal Overdoses in Oregon JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024 · Peer-reviewed study

  • “In this cohort study of fatal overdose and fentanyl spread through Oregon’s unregulated drug market, decriminalization of drug possession was not associated with an increase in fatal drug overdose rates in Oregon in the 2 years after its enactment.”

    Drug Decriminalization, Fentanyl, and Fatal Overdoses in Oregon JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024 · Peer-reviewed study

  • “Synthetic-control estimates show that both policies sharply reduced drug arrests and were followed by sustained increases in overdose mortality relative to matched counterfactuals. The estimates imply approximately 1,186 excess deaths in Oregon and 1,895 in Washington from 2021 through 2023.”

    Did Decriminalization Increase Overdoses? Author page, NBER Working Paper No. 35427, 2026 · Working paper

  • “while accounting for the state's rapid spread of fentanyl in its unregulated drug market as a time-varying covariate.”

    Drug Decriminalization, Fentanyl, and Fatal Overdoses in Oregon JAMA Network Open (open article PDF copy hosted by Substance Use Health Canada), 2024 · Peer-reviewed study

  • “Alternative measures of fentanyl supply continue to yield positive overdose effects.”

    Did Decriminalization Increase Overdoses? Author page, NBER Working Paper No. 35427, 2026 · Working paper

Still open

Who is acting on it now

  1. Ended

    British Columbia's decriminalization exemptionFederal exemption

    BCCDC reports the exemption expired on January 31, 2026, and will not be renewed.

    British Columbia Centre for Disease Control, 2026
    • “The decriminalization exemption expired on January 31, 2026, and will not be renewed, making possession of any amount of illicit substances illegal and enforceable anywhere that does not have an exemption such as supervised consumption and drug checking sites.”

      Decriminalization in B.C. British Columbia Centre for Disease Control, 2026 · Official data British Columbia's public health agency

  2. Scaled back

    Health CanadaFederal health agency

    At British Columbia’s request, Health Canada replaced the exemption with one that bans possession in public spaces and restores police authority there.

    2 sources
    • “On May 7, 2024, due to concerns about substance use in public settings and at the request of BC, Health Canada replaced the exemption with a new s.56 exemption which decriminalizes possession of small amounts of illegal drugs only in specific locations, including:”

      Decriminalization: Data Report to Health Canada, February 2023 to July 2024 Government of British Columbia, 2024 · Government evaluation The provincial government reporting on its own pilot

    • “The intention of the new exemption is to balance goals of public health, public safety, and other community interests by prohibiting the possession (a pre-condition to use) of illegal drugs in public spaces, and reinstating police authority to address problematic substance use in public spaces with a possession offense.”

      Decriminalization: Data Report to Health Canada, February 2023 to July 2024 Government of British Columbia, 2024 · Government evaluation The provincial government reporting on its own pilot

  3. Enacted

    Tina KotekGovernor of Oregon

    Tina Kotek signed House Bill 4002, which restored misdemeanor penalties for possessing small amounts and expanded treatment funding.

    2 sources

Sources

Official data2

Government evaluation3

Peer-reviewed study4

Working paper2

Law or ruling4

News report1

Before the next fight over it

See what happened where they tried it.

The brief follows what politicians propose each morning, in their own words, and links the policy pages when one comes up. Free.

Arrives around 6am ET. Free, and it stays that way.

Cancel anytime. Nothing on the site goes behind a paywall.

One payment through Stripe. No account needed.