Unbiasable

Free public transit · Economy, jobs & inflation

When cities made buses free, did more people ride?

Fare-free transit lets riders board selected routes or a whole network without paying a fare. Some programs cover everyone; others restrict free trips to residents, and some operate only as temporary pilots.

3 sources
  • “From March 1, 2022 through December 31, 2026, MBTA Routes 23, 28, and 29 will be free for all riders.”

    Free Route 23, 28, and 29 Bus Program City of Boston, 2022 · Government evaluation The City of Boston, describing its own program

  • “In Luxembourg, all trips by public train (except for 1st class), tram or bus that do not cross-national borders are free for everyone, including tourists.”

    Free mobility from 1 March 2020 Ministry of Mobility and Public Works, Luxembourg, 2020 · Government evaluation The ministry responsible for Luxembourg's free transit

  • “Since 1 January 2013, public transport has been free for registered residents of Tallinn.”

    Facts of Tallinn 2024 City of Tallinn, 2024 · Official data

The answer so far

Across 16 U.S. agencies that dropped fares, ridership rose 49% on average, with estimates from -24.2% to +122.8%; a 125-agency study found about 17% for partial-route and 45% for full fare-free policies. New York’s five-route pilot added an estimated 24% net weekday riders. Luxembourg saw no major shift from cars to transit that it could attribute to free fares.

5 sources
  • “This study identifies 16 US transit agencies that have recently eliminated fares. A staggered difference-in-differences analysis shows that fare elimination increased ridership by 49%, on average.”

    Fare-Free Transit in the United States: Effects on Ridership, Service, and Finances University of Hawai'i Economic Research Organization, 2026 · Working paper

  • “I find the average system experienced 51% growth in ridership due to fare elimination, with the median estimated as 55%. These estimates are slightly larger but consistent with the 49% increase estimated under the staggered difference-in-differences model. Estimates range from -24.2% (Transfort, Fort Collins, CO) to +122.8% (Hele-On, Hawai'i County, HI).”

    Fare-Free Transit in the United States: Effects on Ridership, Service, and Finances University of Hawai'i Economic Research Organization, 2026 · Working paper

  • “This study assesses the long-term effects of fare-free transit (FFT) policies on ridership, at both the agency and neighborhood levels. Using a Fixed Effects model with Instrumental Variables on data from 125 U.S. transit agencies (2011–2023), we found that partial-route and full FFT policies increased agency-level ridership by approximately 17% and 45%, respectively.”

    Assessing ridership impacts of fare-free transit policies through agency- and neighborhood-level models Journal of Public Transportation, 2026 · Peer-reviewed study

  • “IBO takes the 30% observed increase in weekday ridership across the five pilot routes, subtracting out the 6% in overall system ridership growth during the same period for a net impact of 24%. We use the reported school year changes because this is a longer observation period.”

    Expanding Fair Fares: Many Options, A Range of Costs New York City Independent Budget Office, 2026 · Government evaluation

  • “No significant mode shift has been observed that could unequivocally be attributed to the introduction of free public transport. Besides the fact that such a sudden mode shift was not anticipated (see the previous question), there are several possible explanations for this:”

    Free mobility from 1 March 2020 Ministry of Mobility and Public Works, Luxembourg, 2020 · Government evaluation The ministry responsible for Luxembourg's free transit

Where it was tried

  1. Tallinn, Estonia

    City In force Since Jan 1, 2013

    Since January 1, 2013, public transport has been free for registered Tallinn residents.

    2 sources
    • “Since 1 January 2013, public transport has been free for registered residents of Tallinn.”

      Facts of Tallinn 2024 City of Tallinn, 2024 · Official data

    • “Since 1 January 2013, public transport has been free for registered residents of Tallinn.”

      Facts of Tallinn 2024 City of Tallinn, 2024 · Official data

  2. Kansas City, Missouri

    City Ended 2020 to Jun 1, 2026

    RideKC buses became fare-free in 2020; fares returned on June 1, 2026.

    2 sources
  3. Richmond, Virginia

    City In force Since 2020

    GRTC launched zero fares in 2020, and its budget overview for the coming year would keep them through June 2027.

    2 sources
    • “GRTC officials launched the Zero Fare program in 2020 during the pandemic in an effort to reduce interaction between bus drivers and passengers.”

      GRTC commits to another year of fare-free service The Richmonder, 2026 · News report

    • “Buses in the Richmond region will remain fare-free for another year. “Zero fare is staying,” said Adrienne Torres, GRTC’s chief of staff, during a recent overview of the transit agency’s budget for the coming year, which would maintain the program through the end of June 2027.”

      GRTC commits to another year of fare-free service The Richmonder, 2026 · News report

  4. Luxembourg

    National In force Since Mar 1, 2020

    Luxembourg made domestic bus, tram, and second-class train travel free nationwide in March 2020.

    2 sources
    • “In Luxembourg, all trips by public train (except for 1st class), tram or bus that do not cross-national borders are free for everyone, including tourists.”

      Free mobility from 1 March 2020 Ministry of Mobility and Public Works, Luxembourg, 2020 · Government evaluation The ministry responsible for Luxembourg's free transit

    • “On 1 March 2020, the day when public transport became free in Luxembourg, there were no such changes, including pricing: in Luxembourg, using public transport has always been significantly cheaper than driving a car, even when public transport was still a paid service (50 euros per month or 4 euros per day for the entire country).”

      Free mobility from 1 March 2020 Ministry of Mobility and Public Works, Luxembourg, 2020 · Government evaluation The ministry responsible for Luxembourg's free transit

  5. Boston, Massachusetts

    City In force Since 2021

    Boston made Route 28 free in August 2021; Routes 23, 28 and 29 are scheduled to stay free through December 31, 2026.

    2 sources
    • “After fares were eliminated in August 2021, Route 28, which runs from Mattapan Square along Blue Hill Avenue and then over to Ruggles, became the most popular route in the MBTA bus system.”

      Free Route 23, 28, and 29 Bus Program City of Boston, 2022 · Government evaluation The City of Boston, describing its own program

    • “From March 1, 2022 through December 31, 2026, MBTA Routes 23, 28, and 29 will be free for all riders.”

      Free Route 23, 28, and 29 Bus Program City of Boston, 2022 · Government evaluation The City of Boston, describing its own program

  6. Alexandria, Virginia

    City In force Since Sep 5, 2021

    DASH stopped collecting fares on all its buses on September 5, 2021.

    2 sources
    • “On September 5, 2021, DASH eliminated fare collection on all DASH buses.”

      DASH Fare-Free Program Report Alexandria Transit Company, 2024 · Government evaluation The operator of DASH, reporting on its own program

    • “DASH is 100% fare-free, so riding the bus is as simple and accessible as it gets.”

      Rider Code of Conduct Alexandria Transit Company (DASH), 2026 · Official data The operator of DASH, reporting on its own program

  7. Albuquerque, New Mexico

    City In force Since 2022

    ABQ RIDE started its zero-fare pilot in 2022, and City Council made zero-fare service permanent for all ABQ RIDE services in 2023.

    2 sources
    • “Since the launch of the (now permanent) Zero Fares Pilot Program in January 2022, ridership increased by 20%.”

      7 Million+ Rides Strong: ABQ RIDE is Making a Comeback City of Albuquerque, 2025 · Official data

    • “On Wednesday, November 8, 2023, City Council approved O-23-89, officially making Zero Fares permanent for all services provided by ABQ RIDE.”

      Zero Fares is Here to Stay City of Albuquerque, 2023 · Law or ruling

What the numbers did

Compared with similar places
Measured against places or people that did not adopt it.
Before and after
The same place before and after; other changes at the time can blur it.
Official figures over time
No comparison group, so other changes can blur it.

Ridership across adopting agencies

Went up

Justin Tyndall’s comparison of 16 U.S. transit agencies estimated ridership rose 49% on average after fare elimination.

Compared with similar places
University of Hawai'i Economic Research Organization, 2026

Ridership change by system

Mixed

Justin Tyndall’s system-by-system estimates ranged from -24.2% for Transfort in Fort Collins to +122.8% for Hele-On in Hawai’i County, with average growth of 51%.

Compared with similar places
University of Hawai'i Economic Research Organization, 2026
  • “I find the average system experienced 51% growth in ridership due to fare elimination, with the median estimated as 55%. These estimates are slightly larger but consistent with the 49% increase estimated under the staggered difference-in-differences model. Estimates range from -24.2% (Transfort, Fort Collins, CO) to +122.8% (Hele-On, Hawai'i County, HI).”

    Fare-Free Transit in the United States: Effects on Ridership, Service, and Finances University of Hawai'i Economic Research Organization, 2026 · Working paper

Ridership across transit agencies

Went up

Using 2011-2023 data from 125 U.S. agencies, Diaz-Gutierrez and Ranjbari’s peer-reviewed study estimated ridership rose approximately 17% when some routes were free and 45% when entire systems were free.

Compared with similar places
Journal of Public Transportation, 2026
  • “This study assesses the long-term effects of fare-free transit (FFT) policies on ridership, at both the agency and neighborhood levels. Using a Fixed Effects model with Instrumental Variables on data from 125 U.S. transit agencies (2011–2023), we found that partial-route and full FFT policies increased agency-level ridership by approximately 17% and 45%, respectively.”

    Assessing ridership impacts of fare-free transit policies through agency- and neighborhood-level models Journal of Public Transportation, 2026 · Peer-reviewed study

Weekday ridership across pilot routes

Went up

New York City’s Independent Budget Office estimated a 24% net weekday ridership increase across the pilot routes after subtracting systemwide growth.

Compared with similar places
New York City Independent Budget Office, 2026
  • “IBO takes the 30% observed increase in weekday ridership across the five pilot routes, subtracting out the 6% in overall system ridership growth during the same period for a net impact of 24%. We use the reported school year changes because this is a longer observation period.”

    Expanding Fair Fares: Many Options, A Range of Costs New York City Independent Budget Office, 2026 · Government evaluation

Dwell time per passenger

Went down

A City of Boston page on its fare-free buses reports dwell times per passenger fell by about 20%.

2 sources
  • “After fares were eliminated in August 2021, Route 28, which runs from Mattapan Square along Blue Hill Avenue and then over to Ruggles, became the most popular route in the MBTA bus system.”

    Free Route 23, 28, and 29 Bus Program City of Boston, 2022 · Government evaluation The City of Boston, describing its own program

  • “Dwell times per passenger decreased by about 20%”

    Free Route 23, 28, and 29 Bus Program City of Boston, 2022 · Government evaluation The City of Boston, describing its own program

Weekday boardings on selected DASH routes

Went up

A DASH report said average weekday boardings on these routes rose 119%, slightly more than the system as a whole, though their service was not much improved.

2 sources
  • “On September 5, 2021, DASH eliminated fare collection on all DASH buses.”

    DASH Fare-Free Program Report Alexandria Transit Company, 2024 · Government evaluation The operator of DASH, reporting on its own program

  • “Average weekday boardings for each of these routes have increased by 119%, which is slightly higher than the system as a whole. Since the service on these routes was not significantly improved but the ridership still increased, this finding supports the idea that free fares may be the biggest factor contributing to increased ridership.”

    DASH Fare-Free Program Report Alexandria Transit Company, 2024 · Government evaluation The operator of DASH, reporting on its own program

Mode shift to public transport

No clear change

Luxembourg’s mobility ministry says it has seen no major shift to transit that can be attributed with certainty to free fares, and that such a sudden shift was not expected.

2 sources
  • “On 1 March 2020, the day when public transport became free in Luxembourg, there were no such changes, including pricing: in Luxembourg, using public transport has always been significantly cheaper than driving a car, even when public transport was still a paid service (50 euros per month or 4 euros per day for the entire country).”

    Free mobility from 1 March 2020 Ministry of Mobility and Public Works, Luxembourg, 2020 · Government evaluation The ministry responsible for Luxembourg's free transit

  • “No significant mode shift has been observed that could unequivocally be attributed to the introduction of free public transport. Besides the fact that such a sudden mode shift was not anticipated (see the previous question), there are several possible explanations for this:”

    Free mobility from 1 March 2020 Ministry of Mobility and Public Works, Luxembourg, 2020 · Government evaluation The ministry responsible for Luxembourg's free transit

Where the studies disagree

How much did agency ridership change under fare-free policies?

Justin Tyndall estimated a 49% average increase across 16 U.S. agencies that removed fares.

University of Hawai'i Economic Research Organization, 2026

Diaz-Gutierrez and Ranjbari’s peer-reviewed study estimated approximately 17% for partial-route and 45% for full fare-free policies in a 125-agency sample.

Journal of Public Transportation, 2026
  • “This study assesses the long-term effects of fare-free transit (FFT) policies on ridership, at both the agency and neighborhood levels. Using a Fixed Effects model with Instrumental Variables on data from 125 U.S. transit agencies (2011–2023), we found that partial-route and full FFT policies increased agency-level ridership by approximately 17% and 45%, respectively.”

    Assessing ridership impacts of fare-free transit policies through agency- and neighborhood-level models Journal of Public Transportation, 2026 · Peer-reviewed study

Why they differ

The 17% figure covers partial-route policies; for full fare-free policies the second study’s 45% is close to Tyndall’s 49%, though the samples and methods differ.

2 sources

Did Boston’s free-fare program raise nearby activity?

Joseph, Gibbs, Yabe, and Moro’s geographic comparison found no statistically significant activity increase around Boston’s Route 28.

2 sources

Joseph, Gibbs, Yabe, and Moro estimated that Boston’s free-fare program increased overall activity by approximately 16% using mobility networks.

2 sources
  • “Using large-scale mobility data, we estimate the causal effects of three transportation interventions in Boston and New York City using both conventional geographic and mobility-based definitions of exposure. Geographic designs detect no effects, or even negative ones. When exposure is defined through mobility networks, the same interventions reveal substantial behavioral change.”

    Human mobility shapes how urban policy effects spread across cities arXiv, 2026 · Working paper

  • “Boston's free-fare program increases overall activity by approximately 16%, with more pronounced effects among lower-income communities.”

    Human mobility shapes how urban policy effects spread across cities arXiv, 2026 · Working paper

Why they differ

The result changes with the exposure definition: geographic proximity versus travel patterns in mobility networks.

arXiv, 2026
  • “Using large-scale mobility data, we estimate the causal effects of three transportation interventions in Boston and New York City using both conventional geographic and mobility-based definitions of exposure. Geographic designs detect no effects, or even negative ones. When exposure is defined through mobility networks, the same interventions reveal substantial behavioral change.”

    Human mobility shapes how urban policy effects spread across cities arXiv, 2026 · Working paper

Still open

Who is acting on it now

  1. Proposed

    City of BostonBoston city government

    Mayor Michelle Wu said the city is putting out a request for proposals for operators of a fare-free route pilot.

    2 sources
  2. Ended

    Kansas City Area Transportation AuthorityRegional transit agency

    The Kansas City Area Transportation Authority returned fares to its bus system.

    2 sources
  3. Proposed

    GRTCRichmond regional bus agency

    GRTC’s budget overview for the coming year would keep buses fare-free through June 2027.

    The Richmonder, 2026
    • “Buses in the Richmond region will remain fare-free for another year. “Zero fare is staying,” said Adrienne Torres, GRTC’s chief of staff, during a recent overview of the transit agency’s budget for the coming year, which would maintain the program through the end of June 2027.”

      GRTC commits to another year of fare-free service The Richmonder, 2026 · News report

  4. Proposed

    New York State AssemblyLower house of the New York Legislature

    The New York State Assembly proposed reviving the fare-free bus pilot in its one-house budget plan.

    amNewYork, 2026
  5. Proposed

    New York State SenateUpper house of the New York Legislature

    The New York State Senate proposed reviving and expanding the fare-free bus pilot in its one-house budget resolution.

    amNewYork, 2026
  6. Ended

    New York's free bus pilotState-funded pilot

    On September 1, riders on the pilot’s routes in each borough returned to paying the $2.90 fare.

    Queens Daily Eagle, 2024
    • “Come Sept. 1, riders on routes in each borough, including the Q4 in Jamaica, will return to paying the $2.90 fare for their bus rides. For the last year it was an expense they were spared thanks to the state-funded pilot program.”

      Queens pol says MTA got it wrong when it canned free bus pilot Queens Daily Eagle, 2024 · News report

Sources

Official data4

Government evaluation4

Peer-reviewed study1

Working paper3

Law or ruling1

Before the next fight over it

See what happened where they tried it.

The brief follows what politicians propose each morning, in their own words, and links the policy pages when one comes up. Free.

Arrives around 6am ET. Free, and it stays that way.

Cancel anytime. Nothing on the site goes behind a paywall.

One payment through Stripe. No account needed.