Unbiasable

Bail reform · Guns, crime & policing

When states stopped requiring cash bail, did more people skip court or commit crimes?

Cash bail asks defendants to pay money to secure release before trial. Some bail reforms limit or remove that payment and let judges assess a person’s risk when deciding whether to release them.

2 sources
  • “Cash: The defendant pays the full bail sum in cash and is supposed to have bail returned if the person makes all court hearings.”

    NYC Bail Trends Since 2019 Office of the New York City Comptroller, 2022 · Government evaluation

  • “In its place is a system that allows judges to base pretrial release decisions on a fair and evidenced based assessment of the risk a defendant poses.”

    Annual Report of the New Jersey Court Year 2017-2018 New Jersey Courts, 2018 · Government evaluation

The answer so far

New Jersey’s pretrial jail population fell 20 percent in 2017. In Illinois, missed-hearing warrants fell from 13.6% to 12.5% overall but rose for some felony charges; California’s emergency zero-bail orders raised 30-day rearrests 8.2 percentage points, with no rise in violent-felony rearrests. In New York City, one study found no clear effect on assault, theft or drug crime, another higher violent-felony arrests among people with pending cases.

8 sources

Where it was tried

  1. Cook County, Illinois

    County Expanded Since 2017

    The county court applied its bail hearing order to felony cases first, then all cases.

    Circuit Court of Cook County, 2017
  2. Harris County, Texas

    County In force Since 2017

    A court injunction started misdemeanor bail changes in 2017, followed by a 2019 consent decree governing pretrial release.

    2 sources
  3. New Jersey

    State In force Since 2017

    The state replaced cash bail with a system in which judges make pretrial release decisions.

    2 sources
  4. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

    City In force Since 2018

    The District Attorney’s Office stopped ordinarily requesting cash bail for listed misdemeanor and felony charges, with discretion for exceptions.

    Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office, 2018
    • “Effective February 21, 2018, the District Attorney will ordinarily no longer ask for cash bail for the following misdemeanors and felonies.”

      Philadelphia DAO Policy on Bail Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office, 2018 · Law or ruling

  5. California

    State Repealed 2020 to Jun 10, 2020

    California’s Judicial Council set an emergency bail schedule with presumptive bail at $0, then repealed the rule on June 10, 2020.

    2 sources
  6. New York

    State Scaled back Since 2020

    The state removed bail for some cases in its initial 2020 law, then expanded cash-bail eligibility in a July amendment.

    2 sources
  7. Illinois

    State In force Since 2023

    The Pretrial Fairness Act ended cash bail statewide and moved release or detention decisions to court hearings.

    2 sources

What the numbers did

Compared with similar places
Measured against places or people that did not adopt it.
Before and after
The same place before and after; other changes at the time can blur it.
Official figures over time
No comparison group, so other changes can blur it.

Overall firearm mortality

No clear change

A peer-reviewed New Jersey study found no evidence of increased overall firearm mortality after bail reform.

JAMA Network Open via PubMed Central, 2024

Reported crime in New York City

No clear change

A working paper compared New York City with 27 large cities on five crime types and found no statistically significant effect of bail reform on assault, theft or drug crime.

2 sources

Rearrests within 30 days

Mixed

PPIC researchers found the likelihood of rearrest rose 8.2 percentage points in the 10 weeks after California’s emergency bail orders began. The report found no evidence of increased rearrests for violent felonies.

2 sources
  • “Emergency bail orders increased the likelihood and number of rearrests within 30 days of the initial arrest. The likelihood of rearrest went up by 8.2 percentage points in the 10 weeks following implementation of emergency bail orders”

    What Happened When California Suspended Bail during COVID? Public Policy Institute of California, 2024 · Research organization

  • “However, we find no evidence of an increase in rearrests for violent felonies; in particular, lower-level offenders released on zero bail were not more likely to be rearrested for violent felonies, a concern raised by some observers.”

    What Happened When California Suspended Bail during COVID? Public Policy Institute of California, 2024 · Research organization

People held in jail before trial

Went down

New Jersey Courts reported that the number of people held in jail before trial fell 20 percent in 2017.

New Jersey Courts, 2018

Missed-hearing warrants overall and by age and race

Went down

Loyola researchers found warrants after missed hearings fell from 13.6% before the Pretrial Fairness Act to 12.5% after; older, white defendants and those facing more serious charges had higher rates.

2 sources

Missed-hearing warrants for some felony charges

Went up

Loyola researchers found missed-hearing warrants among defendants charged with non-detainable felonies rose from 13.1% to 16.1% after the Act.

Loyola University Chicago Center for Criminal Justice, 2024
  • “Specifically, those charged with non-detainable felonies (Class 3 and higher felonies detainable only under the little-used willful flight standard and Class 4 non-detainable felonies) saw the largest increase, from 13.1% before the PFA to 16.1% after the PFA.”

    The First Year of the Pretrial Fairness Act Loyola University Chicago Center for Criminal Justice, 2024 · Research organization

Reported crime in Illinois

Went down

Loyola researchers found reported crime fell 11% in Illinois in the first six months of 2024 versus the same 2023 period; violent crime fell 7%, and property crime 14%. The report says these figures do not isolate the law’s effect.

3 sources
  • “Using data collected by the Illinois State Police through the National Incident Based Reporting System (NIBRS), we compared reported crime in each of Illinois’ counties during the first six months of 2023 (before the PFA) with crime reported during the first six months of 2024 (after the PFA).”

    The First Year of the Pretrial Fairness Act Loyola University Chicago Center for Criminal Justice, 2024 · Research organization

  • “The statewide volume of reported crimes declined 11% between the two periods. Violent crime declined 7%, and property crime declined 14%.”

    The First Year of the Pretrial Fairness Act Loyola University Chicago Center for Criminal Justice, 2024 · Research organization

  • “This does not answer the question of the PFA’s impact, if any, on crime and public safety.”

    The First Year of the Pretrial Fairness Act Loyola University Chicago Center for Criminal Justice, 2024 · Research organization

Released defendants charged with indictable offenses

Mixed

New Jersey Courts reported the share of released defendants charged with indictable offenses rose to 20.3 percent in 2020, the first pandemic year, then was 20.7 percent in 2021 and 20.5 percent in 2022.

New Jersey Courts, 2025
  • “the first year of the pandemic (2020) the number of defendants charged with indictable offenses while on pretrial release increased to 20.3 percent. The percentage remained relatively the same the next two years - 20.7 percent in 2021 and 20.5 percent in 2022. The rate then declined in 2023 as 17.6 percent of defendants released pretrial that year were charged with indictable offenses while on pretrial release.”

    Criminal Justice Reform: 2022-2024 New Jersey Courts, 2025 · Government evaluation

Court appearances after release

No clear change

New Jersey Courts reported more than 90 percent of defendants appeared for court each year from 2021 to 2023.

New Jersey Courts, 2025
  • “more than 90 percent of defendants showing up for court each year from 2021 to 2023.”

    Criminal Justice Reform: 2022-2024 New Jersey Courts, 2025 · Government evaluation

Where the studies disagree

Why do New York findings differ across outcomes?

A Data Collaborative study found a statistically significant increase in arrests for violent felonies before trial among defendants with a separate pending case.

2 sources

A working paper found no clear effect on assault, theft or drug crime after comparing New York City with a group built from other cities.

2 sources

Why they differ

One study tracked new arrests among defendants with another pending case; the other measured citywide reported crime against a comparison group built from other cities.

3 sources

Did missed-hearing warrant rates move the same way across Illinois?

Loyola researchers found warrants after missed court hearings declined from 13.6% before the Pretrial Fairness Act to 12.5% after it.

Loyola University Chicago Center for Criminal Justice, 2024

The same report found missed-hearing warrants among defendants charged with non-detainable felonies rose from 13.1% to 16.1%.

Loyola University Chicago Center for Criminal Justice, 2024
  • “Specifically, those charged with non-detainable felonies (Class 3 and higher felonies detainable only under the little-used willful flight standard and Class 4 non-detainable felonies) saw the largest increase, from 13.1% before the PFA to 16.1% after the PFA.”

    The First Year of the Pretrial Fairness Act Loyola University Chicago Center for Criminal Justice, 2024 · Research organization

Why they differ

The first figure is the overall warrant rate; the second covers defendants charged with non-detainable felonies, the group with the largest increase.

2 sources
  • “from 13.6% before the PFA to 12.5% after”

    The First Year of the Pretrial Fairness Act Loyola University Chicago Center for Criminal Justice, 2024 · Research organization

  • “Specifically, those charged with non-detainable felonies (Class 3 and higher felonies detainable only under the little-used willful flight standard and Class 4 non-detainable felonies) saw the largest increase, from 13.1% before the PFA to 16.1% after the PFA.”

    The First Year of the Pretrial Fairness Act Loyola University Chicago Center for Criminal Justice, 2024 · Research organization

Still open

Who is acting on it now

  1. Voted for

    Indiana votersState electorate

    With 84% of votes counted, Indiana’s Public Question 1, letting judges hold more defendants without bail, passed with 59%.

    2 sources
    • “Hoosiers easily approved two constitutional amendments Tuesday, including one that will allow judges to hold more criminal defendants without bail.”

      Voters change Indiana’s Constitution — twice WTHI-TV / Indiana Capital Chronicle, 2026 · News report

    • “Public Question 1 — the bail change — passed with 59% of the vote. A second question allowing city and town judges to live outside the jurisdiction also passed with 63%. That was with 84% of the votes tallied.”

      Voters change Indiana’s Constitution — twice WTHI-TV / Indiana Capital Chronicle, 2026 · News report

  2. Voted for

    U.S. House of RepresentativesFederal legislature

    The House passed H.R. 5214, requiring mandatory detention for crimes of violence and dangerous crimes and mandatory cash bail for certain offenses in the District of Columbia.

    2 sources
    • “Mr. COMER. Mr. Speaker, pursuant to House Resolution 879, I call up the bill (H.R. 5214) to require mandatory pretrial and post conviction detention for crimes of violence and dangerous crimes and require mandatory cash bail for certain offenses that pose a threat to public safety or order in the District of Columbia, and for other purposes, and ask for its immediate consideration.”

      Congressional Record: House Proceedings, November 19, 2025 U.S. Government Publishing Office, 2025 · Law or ruling

    • “So the bill was passed. The result of the vote was announced as above recorded. A motion to reconsider was laid on the table.”

      Congressional Record: House Proceedings, November 19, 2025 U.S. Government Publishing Office, 2025 · Law or ruling

  3. Enacted

    President Donald TrumpU.S. president

    Trump’s executive order directed federal agencies to identify funds for cashless-bail jurisdictions that could be suspended or terminated.

    Office of the Federal Register, 2025
    • “The head of each executive department and agency, in coordination with the Director of the Office of Management and Budget, shall identify Federal funds, including grants and contracts, currently provided to cashless bail jurisdictions identified pursuant to subsection (a) of this section that may be suspended or terminated, as appropriate and consistent with applicable law.”

      Taking Steps To End Cashless Bail To Protect Americans Office of the Federal Register, 2025 · Law or ruling

  4. Sued

    Two Atlanta womenPeople detained in Georgia

    Two women sued Georgia over its law requiring cash bail for more crimes under Senate Bill 63.

    2 sources
  5. Proposed

    Sen. Sharif StreetPennsylvania state senator

    Street proposed ending cash bail in Pennsylvania; his bill prohibiting cash bail was referred to the Judiciary Committee.

    3 sources
  6. Enacted

    Georgia General AssemblyState legislature

    Georgia enacted SB 63, adding 30 offenses to the state’s bail-restricted list.

    2 sources
  7. Enacted

    Illinois Supreme CourtState supreme court

    The Illinois Supreme Court changed appeal rules for Pretrial Fairness Act detention cases, effective April 15, 2024.

    State of Illinois Office of the Illinois Courts, 2024

Sources

Government evaluation5

Peer-reviewed study1

Working paper1

Research organization5

Law or ruling8

News report3

Before the next fight over it

See what happened where they tried it.

The brief follows what politicians propose each morning, in their own words, and links the policy pages when one comes up. Free.

Arrives around 6am ET. Free, and it stays that way.

Cancel anytime. Nothing on the site goes behind a paywall.

One payment through Stripe. No account needed.