Feds ask Alaska to set aside every ballot ranking the second Dan Sullivan

Alaska's U.S. attorney confirmed a criminal investigation and a "significant surge of law enforcement assets" after a New York Times report tied Mary Peltola's campaign to recruiting the retired teacher, and Peltola says she knew nothing about it.
The alleged recruitment of a second Dan Sullivan to run for Senate in Alaska broke the law.
“this is criminal behavior to steal the Alaska Senate race, it's now been fully exposed”Fox NewsOct 31
“Not a single illegal thing happened here.”The GuardianOct 31
Open the record1 question in dispute · 7 of 10 sides covered · facts and sources
The facts7 points
- The Justice Department sued Alaska in federal court on Oct. 23, 2026. The suit argues that two Senate candidates with similar names could mislead voters. The ballot for Nov. 3 lists incumbent Dan S. Sullivan, Democrat Mary Peltola, and Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired Petersburg teacher. (Source)
- The suit seeks to stop Alaska officials from certifying the result if the Republican incumbent loses. Alaska election officials have asked a federal judge to dismiss it. (Source)
- A New York Times report, published around Oct. 28, said text messages showed Peltola campaign members discussing recruiting people named Dan Sullivan. The report said they eventually contacted the Petersburg teacher, who qualified for the ballot. (Source)
Show 4 more factsShow fewer
- Peltola's campaign said it "has no involvement with either Sullivan campaign." Daniel J. Sullivan said he had "Zero, none, zilch" contact with her campaign. (Source)
- A state elections official initially ruled Daniel J. Sullivan ineligible. The Alaska Supreme Court reversed that ruling, and he stayed on the ballot. (Source)
- Reporting describes a Justice Department criminal investigation into how Daniel J. Sullivan got on the ballot. Prosecutors are preparing orders telling phone companies to preserve texts and emails. (Source)
- President Trump posted that "Peltola should suffer the Legal and Political consequences." (Source)
How outlets handled it7 source groups · original passages and links
Far Left
“The real aim of Trump and the DOJ is to overturn the result of the election if it is unfavorable to the Republican Party, either through an appeal to the US Supreme Court, packed with Trump supporters, or by having the Republican majority in the US Senate refuse to seat Peltola if she wins.”World Socialist Web Site · arguing the federal lawsuit and Trump's demand are a setup to nullify a Peltola win
“Even if true in every detail, the scheme outlined by the Times is not illegal, but part of the everyday manipulation of capitalist politics under the two-party system.”World Socialist Web Site · dismissing the Peltola recruitment allegation as ordinary two-party maneuvering, not a crime
the WSWS called the alleged scheme, even if every detail is true. It argued that "The real aim of Trump and the DOJ is to overturn the result of the election if it is unfavorable to the Republican Party." Both WSWS pieces treated the probe as preparation for a stolen seat.
Read the original ›Liberal
“To me, that’s voter fraud at the highest level.”President Donald Trump, quoted by CNN · saying Peltola and Dan J. Sullivan should be prosecuted, as DOJ widens its criminal probe
“Some inside the department privately admit that the Alaska lawsuit, which is all but destined to fail, still serves a purpose by creating headlines”CNN, reporting on Justice Department insiders, quoted by CNN · suggesting the suit is meant to generate fraud warnings to voters rather than win in court
CNN wrote of the department's pre-election activity, and it reported that some officials privately call the lawsuit "all but destined to fail." NBC noted the filing did not explain how reviewing a ballot would show confusion, and MSNBC wrote that Trump "offered no evidence directly linking Peltola to the effort." David Pakman turned to…
Read the original ›Center
“seeks to preserve and segregate all ballots ranking Daniel J. Sullivan for the purposes of investigating whether such ranking was the product of voter confusion, should such an investigation become necessary.”Assistant U.S. Attorney E. Bryan Wilson, in a court filing, quoted by PBS NewsHour · the government's request to set aside every ballot ranking the second Sullivan days before the election
“I knew nothing about any other candidates on the ballot except for me and the incumbent. That is all I have ever known about”Mary Peltola, Democratic Senate candidate, quoted by PBS NewsHour · denying any knowledge of the effort to recruit the second Dan Sullivan
the AP copy on PBS noted. A second PBS piece added that "Political parties often support extra candidates on ballots to try to pull votes from their rivals," and the BBC quoted an Alaska lawyer skeptical that any law was broken.
Read the original ›Center-Right
“Because Alaska has ranked-choice voting so even if a Dan Sullivan voter picked the wrong Dan Sullivan first, she would presumably pick the other Dan Sullivan second.”The Bulwark (JVL newsletter) · arguing ranked-choice voting neutralizes any vote-splitting effect of the decoy candidate
“We live in a world where legality is the standard. Mary Peltola’s dirty trick was legal.”The Bulwark (JVL newsletter) · rejecting calls to prosecute Peltola or block certification of her win
JVL wrote of the trick, adding "This is what hardball looks like." The camp split sharply: The Dispatch opened its podcast on "anti-democratic efforts by Democrats to confuse voters in the Alaska Senate race." The Examiner relayed the department's line that it wants to "not change votes or declare a winner." [263][291][279][273]
Read the original ›Libertarian
MAGA
“Cheating” is the only way to describe the Democratic plot in Alaska to put another Dan Sullivan on the Senate ballot to confuse voters.Nicholas C. Fondacaro, Media Research Center associate editor (via The Daily Wire) · framing the second Sullivan's candidacy as deliberate Democratic election cheating
“I think it stinks to high heaven. I suspected it was the case when we talked about the other day, but I didn’t want to say it until it was confirmed through reporting.”Alyssa Farah Griffin, co-host of ABC's The View, quoted by The Daily Wire · conceding the Times report made the Peltola-camp recruitment allegation look credible
Cheating "is the only way to describe the Democratic plot in Alaska," one Daily Wire piece declared, and the Federalist framed it as "a scheme to confuse voters" that exposes Democratic opposition to the SAVE Act.
Read the original ›Religious Right
“He was just put there as a fraud. But people aren't going to know that. So nobody is going to know what to do.”Donald Trump, President, quoted by CBN News · claiming the second Dan Sullivan was planted to confuse Alaska voters
“I knew nothing about any other candidates on the ballot except for me and the incumbent.”Mary Peltola, Democratic Senate candidate, quoted by CBN News · denying any role in recruiting the second Sullivan as the governor opens an investigation
is how CBN framed the state inquiry. It carried Trump calling it a fraud and Peltola's denial side by side.
Read the original ›- Oct 29 – today · 2 days48 articles · 8 of 10 sides
- TodayFeds ask Alaska to set aside every ballot ranking the second Dan Sullivan
- Oct 29Times report says Peltola's campaign recruited a second Dan Sullivan for Alaska's ballot
The sources, this chapterFar Left2 articles
Liberal10 articles
- Justice Department's Dan Sullivan criminal probe accelerates after Alaska campaign revelations
- DOJ calls Alaska Senate allegations "troubling," asks to segregate ballots
- DOJ requests separating Alaska ballots that rank Dan J. Sullivan in Senate race
- Stumping in Florida, Trump doubles down on calls for Peltola's prosecution in Alaska Senate race
- DOJ seeks to isolate ballots in Alaska Senate race amid investigation
- Alaska prosecutor investigates alleged Democratic plot to confuse voters with second Dan Sullivan
- Alaska's Senate race faces claims of spoiler candidate. And, Hegseth ousts Army general
- Yale graduate JD Vance can't figure THIS out
- Alaska Democrats played into Trump’s hands with Dan Sullivan ballot-stacking effort
- Breaking down the report alleging Mary Peltola's campaign recruited a second Dan Sullivan in Alaska
Center7 articles
- Top federal prosecutor in Alaska says criminal probe underway over would-be spoiler Senate candidate
- Peltola denies knowing about Alaska spoiler candidate as Justice Department escalates investigation
- Candidates make final midterm stops as early voting surges
- Alaska Senate candidate denies knowing about alleged plot to put two Dan Sullivans on ballot
- Trump calls for prosecution of Alaska Senate candidate Peltola over Sullivan name controversy
- WATCH: Trump calls for Peltola to drop out after report her campaign helped recruit 2nd Dan Sullivan
- Democratic and GOP strategists assess midterm landscape in final week
Center-Right5 articles
Libertarian3 articles
MAGA18 articles
- 'The View' Doesn't See A Problem With Democrats Cheating in Alaska
- What The Law Can Actually Do About The Other Dan Sullivan
- Feds Address Dirty Dem Plot To Dupe Voters In Critical Alaska Senate Race
- Sen. Johnson Launches Probe Into Alaska's 'Decoy Dan' Senate Race Scandal
- Report: Russia Hoaxer Marc Elias' Firm Was 'Part Of' Peltola Plot To Rig Alaska Ballot
- DOJ Claims Mary Peltola, Democrats Misled Federal Court on Second Dan Sullivan Candidate Scheme
- Report: Alaska's Second Dan Sullivan Leaves Hometown Days Before Election
- Peltola insists 'I knew nothing' about alleged 'Decoy Dan' scheme as Sullivan alleges she is 'still lying'
- RNC rejects narrative of spoiler candidates 'on both sides,' calls Alaska scheme 'fraudulent'
- Democrats PANIC As DOJ Fraud Probe EXPANDS, Trump Says BLOCK Election Results
- NY Times exposes Alaska Democrat's alleged hunt for another Dan Sullivan to run against Republican
- Mary Peltola's campaign, Dems backed covert scheme to field spoiler candidates in Alaska Senate race: report
- Peltola campaign's alleged Dan Sullivan spoiler plot takes new turn as DOJ faces major legal hurdle
- Report: Mary Peltola Was Aware of Scheme to Draft Spoiler Candidate with Dan Sullivan's Name -- and Her Campaign Lawyers Were Involved
- DOJ Intensifies ‘Aggressive Criminal Investigation’ into Alaska’s Second Dan Sullivan
- Trump: Democrats' Fake Alaska Senate Candidate Scheme 'A Fraud on the American Public'
- Booker: Dems Stacking Ballot in Alaska with Fake Dan Sullivan 'Much Ado About Nothing'
- Trump Accuses Dems Of ‘Fake’ Candidate Scheme In Crucial Senate Race






































